Abstract
This thesis presents a multi-stage, evidence-informed process for developing a Whole School Approach (WSA) to supporting primary school learners with dyslexia in Northern Ireland. The work is explicitly aligned with the Medical Research Council’s 6SQUiD framework (Six Stages in Quality Intervention Development; Wight et al., 2016), which provides a structured pathway for designing complex interventions. The six stages are as follows:1. Define and understand the problem and its causes
2. Clarify which causal or contextual factors are malleable and have greatest scope for change
3. Identify how to bring about change: the change mechanism
4. Identify how to deliver the change mechanism
5. Test and refine on a small scale
6. Collect sufficient evidence of effectiveness to justify rigorous evaluation or wider implementation.
This thesis addresses the first four stages of the 6SQUiD model. It begins by defining the scope of the problem through a scoping review of Whole School Approaches in dyslexia support, then explores modifiable contextual barriers through focus groups with key stakeholders including educators, parents, and pupils. The third stage employs a Delphi consensus process to identify feasible and evidence-based mechanisms of change, culminating in the development of a co-designed Logic Model in Stage 4. This Logic Model represents a theory-driven framework to guide implementation of a WSA for dyslexia that is inclusive, practical, and responsive to school-level realities.
Stages 5 and 6—testing, refining, and evaluating the intervention—are beyond the scope of this doctoral research. However, a brief framework document was developed for use by schools to aid in the development and evaluation of their own WSA. Members of the steering group also provided some social validity feedback on this document in relation to how useful it would be to their school teams. By building a rigorous foundation of theoretical, empirical, and stakeholder-informed evidence, this thesis offers a scalable platform from which to advance dyslexia support in schools through sustainable, system-level intervention. The scoping review identified considerable variability in how Whole School Approaches are conceptualised and implemented internationally, alongside a frequent absence of explicit theoretical underpinning and limited clarity around evaluation processes. Focus group findings revealed persistent systemic barriers within Northern Irish primary schools, including inconsistent professional development, leadership variability, resource constraints, and limited structured parental involvement, while strongly endorsing inclusive practice and the centrality of pupil voice. The Delphi study established robust cross-professional consensus on core components of an effective WSA, including structured literacy instruction, leadership accountability, mandatory and ongoing dyslexia training, support beyond formal diagnosis, and systematic whole-school evaluation, while excluding externally led implementation models as non-essential. The findings of this thesis support the implementation of structured, theory-informed Whole School Approaches to dyslexia and offer clear recommendations for leadership-led professional development, inclusive literacy practices, and the use of embedded evaluation to support sustained improvement in Northern Irish primary schools.
| Date of Award | Mar 2026 |
|---|---|
| Original language | English |
| Supervisor | Claire McDowell (Supervisor) & Una O'Connor Bones (Supervisor) |
Keywords
- whole school approach
- dyslexia
- primary education
- 6SQUiD
- logic model
- delphi Study
- inclusive education
- implementation of science
Cite this
- Standard