Abstract
This thesis examines the use of collaborative audiovisual storytelling in post-conflict Northern Ireland by analysing the production of, and audience and participant responses to, two documentary films. Unheard Voices tells the stories of six people who lost a loved one or were injured as a result of the conflict. Unseen Women: Stories from Armagh Gaol, a documentary and multi-screen gallery installation tells the stories of seven women who experienced Armagh Gaol during the Troubles including loyalist and republican former political prisoners, a prison officer and tutors.Participant responses to engaging in the processes of filming, editing and exhibiting their stories confirm the potential benefits of collaborative audiovisual storytelling of this kind. This approach provides validation through public acknowledgement of the trauma narrative; it is cathartic; it externalises a previously internalised trauma narrative by producing a tangible outcome in the form of a DVD; it is a private and public act of memorialisation of a loved one or personal experience and gives an overall sense of achievement.
Audiences responded positively to both films with the majority agreeing that they are effective in the areas of representation, acknowledgment, transition from conflict and educating future generations because it contains first-person storytelling directly from those affected by the Troubles. This humanises the conflict, allowing audiences to emotionally connect with trauma narratives. Audiences felt that the conflict should be remembered, and that public screenings of stories of those affected helps us to do so. This promotes learning from the past with the aim of preventing future conflict.
Although promising, these benefits are not guaranteed. This research also identifies specific risks to participants, i.e. re-traumatisation, misrepresentation and public invalidation of the trauma narrative. Audience responses highlighted the limitations of the editing framework in providing in-depth, adequately contextualised, challenging representations of the complexities of conflict and the intricacies of the remembering/forgetting dialectic and its role in maintaining current and future peace.
Overall, despite its limitations, the collaborative and inclusive filmmaking methodologies devised here offer a model of reparative remembering in the Northern Irish context of selective commemoration that seeks to reduce, as opposed to reinforce, the sense of the ‘other.’
| Date of Award | Dec 2013 |
|---|---|
| Original language | English |
| Sponsors | Department of Employment and Learning |
| Supervisor | Cahal McLaughlin (Supervisor) & Martin McLoone (Supervisor) |
Keywords
- audiovisual storytelling
- post-conflict
- Northern Ireland
- trauma
- memory
- documentary
Cite this
- Standard