Understanding Disadvantage Partly through an Epistemology of Ignorance

Dermot Feenan

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    11 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    This article is concerned with the way in which ignorance is actively constituted orreproduced as an aspect of power. The significance of ignorance as an important siteof study is suggested in this article through an examination of the results of a surveyof applications by women for Silk, in recognition of senior status as an advocate, andjudicial office in Northern Ireland. The survey found that in the male-dominatedprofession of law more women than men were unsure of criteria for appointment.The survey revealed also a different perceptual world between male and femalelawyers and judges in terms of identifying disadvantage on the basis of gender. Malebarristers were twice as likely as female barristers to state that female barristers werenot under-represented in applications for Silk. None of the male judges acknowledgedthat the culture of the bench was male, while most women said it was. This survey issupported by analogous illustrations from other fields. The article concludes thatthe study of ignorance should be added to the field of vision of those working on theintersection of power/knowledge, and that identification of ignorance may requiredistinctive responses. The general observations in this article may be of relevance inother areas of anti-discrimination and equality law, policy and praxis.
    LanguageEnglish
    Pages509-531
    JournalSocial and Legal Studies
    Volume16
    Issue number4
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2007

    Fingerprint

    epistemology
    Law
    affirmative action
    equality
    examination
    gender

    Cite this

    @article{0236df98c8ce4ef6b93d4b6771d7b62d,
    title = "Understanding Disadvantage Partly through an Epistemology of Ignorance",
    abstract = "This article is concerned with the way in which ignorance is actively constituted orreproduced as an aspect of power. The significance of ignorance as an important siteof study is suggested in this article through an examination of the results of a surveyof applications by women for Silk, in recognition of senior status as an advocate, andjudicial office in Northern Ireland. The survey found that in the male-dominatedprofession of law more women than men were unsure of criteria for appointment.The survey revealed also a different perceptual world between male and femalelawyers and judges in terms of identifying disadvantage on the basis of gender. Malebarristers were twice as likely as female barristers to state that female barristers werenot under-represented in applications for Silk. None of the male judges acknowledgedthat the culture of the bench was male, while most women said it was. This survey issupported by analogous illustrations from other fields. The article concludes thatthe study of ignorance should be added to the field of vision of those working on theintersection of power/knowledge, and that identification of ignorance may requiredistinctive responses. The general observations in this article may be of relevance inother areas of anti-discrimination and equality law, policy and praxis.",
    author = "Dermot Feenan",
    year = "2007",
    doi = "10.1177/0964663907082733",
    language = "English",
    volume = "16",
    pages = "509--531",
    journal = "Social and Legal Studies",
    issn = "0964-6639",
    number = "4",

    }

    Understanding Disadvantage Partly through an Epistemology of Ignorance. / Feenan, Dermot.

    In: Social and Legal Studies, Vol. 16, No. 4, 2007, p. 509-531.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Understanding Disadvantage Partly through an Epistemology of Ignorance

    AU - Feenan, Dermot

    PY - 2007

    Y1 - 2007

    N2 - This article is concerned with the way in which ignorance is actively constituted orreproduced as an aspect of power. The significance of ignorance as an important siteof study is suggested in this article through an examination of the results of a surveyof applications by women for Silk, in recognition of senior status as an advocate, andjudicial office in Northern Ireland. The survey found that in the male-dominatedprofession of law more women than men were unsure of criteria for appointment.The survey revealed also a different perceptual world between male and femalelawyers and judges in terms of identifying disadvantage on the basis of gender. Malebarristers were twice as likely as female barristers to state that female barristers werenot under-represented in applications for Silk. None of the male judges acknowledgedthat the culture of the bench was male, while most women said it was. This survey issupported by analogous illustrations from other fields. The article concludes thatthe study of ignorance should be added to the field of vision of those working on theintersection of power/knowledge, and that identification of ignorance may requiredistinctive responses. The general observations in this article may be of relevance inother areas of anti-discrimination and equality law, policy and praxis.

    AB - This article is concerned with the way in which ignorance is actively constituted orreproduced as an aspect of power. The significance of ignorance as an important siteof study is suggested in this article through an examination of the results of a surveyof applications by women for Silk, in recognition of senior status as an advocate, andjudicial office in Northern Ireland. The survey found that in the male-dominatedprofession of law more women than men were unsure of criteria for appointment.The survey revealed also a different perceptual world between male and femalelawyers and judges in terms of identifying disadvantage on the basis of gender. Malebarristers were twice as likely as female barristers to state that female barristers werenot under-represented in applications for Silk. None of the male judges acknowledgedthat the culture of the bench was male, while most women said it was. This survey issupported by analogous illustrations from other fields. The article concludes thatthe study of ignorance should be added to the field of vision of those working on theintersection of power/knowledge, and that identification of ignorance may requiredistinctive responses. The general observations in this article may be of relevance inother areas of anti-discrimination and equality law, policy and praxis.

    U2 - 10.1177/0964663907082733

    DO - 10.1177/0964663907082733

    M3 - Article

    VL - 16

    SP - 509

    EP - 531

    JO - Social and Legal Studies

    T2 - Social and Legal Studies

    JF - Social and Legal Studies

    SN - 0964-6639

    IS - 4

    ER -