Ulster Scots identity and culture: The missing voices

K Stapleton, J Wilson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

20 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In recent years, the Ulster Scots cultural movement has become increasingly prominent, primarily among Protestants/unionists, in Northern Ireland. This movement is frequently seen as a form of cultural unionism that has emerged in response to sociopolitical change. Thus, Ulster Scots is typically seen as a response to the growing confidence of Irish nationalist culture and to a sense of dislocation among unionists in the face of UK devolution and changing conceptions of `Britishness.' These notions reflect a potential politicisation of the movement and have led many to question the `authenticity'(of an Ulster Scots communal identity. In this article, we acknowledge the importance of sociopolitical conditions for the emergence of the Ulster Scots culture/identity. However, we challenge the suggestion implicit in much,academic and nonacademic writing that this culture/identity is somehow contrived in response to such developments. Drawing on interviews and focus group discussions, we show the significance of Ulster Scots as a means of self-understanding and identification in everyday society. Crucially, these interviews were conducted not only with political and cultural leaders (who have hitherto been the focus of Ulster Scots research), but also with `grass-roots' Ulster Scots people, for whom the official movement holds varying degrees of importance. We demonstrate that Ulster Scots functions as a cultural resource not only at the macro-level of official rhetoric, but also at the micro-levels of identity formation, self-understanding, and communal consciousness. We conclude that Ulster Scots is a `real' and lived experience for a self-defined community and, hence, functions similarly to any cultural identity category.
LanguageEnglish
Pages563-591
JournalIDENTITIES-GLOBAL STUDIES IN CULTURE AND POWER
Volume11
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2004

Fingerprint

politicization
identity formation
interview
macro level
cultural identity
micro level
authenticity
group discussion
decentralization
consciousness
rhetoric
confidence
leader
resources
community
experience
Society

Cite this

@article{37940242da8b44199eb15e259da0ad5c,
title = "Ulster Scots identity and culture: The missing voices",
abstract = "In recent years, the Ulster Scots cultural movement has become increasingly prominent, primarily among Protestants/unionists, in Northern Ireland. This movement is frequently seen as a form of cultural unionism that has emerged in response to sociopolitical change. Thus, Ulster Scots is typically seen as a response to the growing confidence of Irish nationalist culture and to a sense of dislocation among unionists in the face of UK devolution and changing conceptions of `Britishness.' These notions reflect a potential politicisation of the movement and have led many to question the `authenticity'(of an Ulster Scots communal identity. In this article, we acknowledge the importance of sociopolitical conditions for the emergence of the Ulster Scots culture/identity. However, we challenge the suggestion implicit in much,academic and nonacademic writing that this culture/identity is somehow contrived in response to such developments. Drawing on interviews and focus group discussions, we show the significance of Ulster Scots as a means of self-understanding and identification in everyday society. Crucially, these interviews were conducted not only with political and cultural leaders (who have hitherto been the focus of Ulster Scots research), but also with `grass-roots' Ulster Scots people, for whom the official movement holds varying degrees of importance. We demonstrate that Ulster Scots functions as a cultural resource not only at the macro-level of official rhetoric, but also at the micro-levels of identity formation, self-understanding, and communal consciousness. We conclude that Ulster Scots is a `real' and lived experience for a self-defined community and, hence, functions similarly to any cultural identity category.",
author = "K Stapleton and J Wilson",
year = "2004",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1080/10702890490883867",
language = "English",
volume = "11",
pages = "563--591",
journal = "Identities",
issn = "1070-289X",
number = "4",

}

Ulster Scots identity and culture: The missing voices. / Stapleton, K; Wilson, J.

In: IDENTITIES-GLOBAL STUDIES IN CULTURE AND POWER, Vol. 11, No. 4, 10.2004, p. 563-591.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Ulster Scots identity and culture: The missing voices

AU - Stapleton, K

AU - Wilson, J

PY - 2004/10

Y1 - 2004/10

N2 - In recent years, the Ulster Scots cultural movement has become increasingly prominent, primarily among Protestants/unionists, in Northern Ireland. This movement is frequently seen as a form of cultural unionism that has emerged in response to sociopolitical change. Thus, Ulster Scots is typically seen as a response to the growing confidence of Irish nationalist culture and to a sense of dislocation among unionists in the face of UK devolution and changing conceptions of `Britishness.' These notions reflect a potential politicisation of the movement and have led many to question the `authenticity'(of an Ulster Scots communal identity. In this article, we acknowledge the importance of sociopolitical conditions for the emergence of the Ulster Scots culture/identity. However, we challenge the suggestion implicit in much,academic and nonacademic writing that this culture/identity is somehow contrived in response to such developments. Drawing on interviews and focus group discussions, we show the significance of Ulster Scots as a means of self-understanding and identification in everyday society. Crucially, these interviews were conducted not only with political and cultural leaders (who have hitherto been the focus of Ulster Scots research), but also with `grass-roots' Ulster Scots people, for whom the official movement holds varying degrees of importance. We demonstrate that Ulster Scots functions as a cultural resource not only at the macro-level of official rhetoric, but also at the micro-levels of identity formation, self-understanding, and communal consciousness. We conclude that Ulster Scots is a `real' and lived experience for a self-defined community and, hence, functions similarly to any cultural identity category.

AB - In recent years, the Ulster Scots cultural movement has become increasingly prominent, primarily among Protestants/unionists, in Northern Ireland. This movement is frequently seen as a form of cultural unionism that has emerged in response to sociopolitical change. Thus, Ulster Scots is typically seen as a response to the growing confidence of Irish nationalist culture and to a sense of dislocation among unionists in the face of UK devolution and changing conceptions of `Britishness.' These notions reflect a potential politicisation of the movement and have led many to question the `authenticity'(of an Ulster Scots communal identity. In this article, we acknowledge the importance of sociopolitical conditions for the emergence of the Ulster Scots culture/identity. However, we challenge the suggestion implicit in much,academic and nonacademic writing that this culture/identity is somehow contrived in response to such developments. Drawing on interviews and focus group discussions, we show the significance of Ulster Scots as a means of self-understanding and identification in everyday society. Crucially, these interviews were conducted not only with political and cultural leaders (who have hitherto been the focus of Ulster Scots research), but also with `grass-roots' Ulster Scots people, for whom the official movement holds varying degrees of importance. We demonstrate that Ulster Scots functions as a cultural resource not only at the macro-level of official rhetoric, but also at the micro-levels of identity formation, self-understanding, and communal consciousness. We conclude that Ulster Scots is a `real' and lived experience for a self-defined community and, hence, functions similarly to any cultural identity category.

U2 - 10.1080/10702890490883867

DO - 10.1080/10702890490883867

M3 - Article

VL - 11

SP - 563

EP - 591

JO - Identities

T2 - Identities

JF - Identities

SN - 1070-289X

IS - 4

ER -