The Reemergence of the Disappeared, the Role of Remains, and the ‘Forensic Gaze’

Research output: Contribution to journalSpecial issue

Abstract

This paper explores what happens when the disappeared, reappear; considering how efforts to discovery and identify physical bodies are received, and what impact they have in exorcising the ghosts of the past. It discusses, following Gatti, the range of “catastrophes” that disappearance provokes, suggesting that reappearance, whether of living persons or human remains, can also lead to catastrophe. The piece argues that ‘civic management’ of disappearance creates a problematic new form of ‘citizenship’, paradoxically conferring special status that those disappeared were rarely afforded prior to their disappearance. Drawing on examples from Latin America and Northern Ireland, the piece considers how bodies without identities, like names without known destinies, disrupt social life, make claims on the living, and/or accuse perpetrators. It considers how forensic ‘truth regimes’ based on Western scientific principles sit alongside other ways of communing with the dead or disappeared.
LanguageEnglish
JournalMemory Studies
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 1 Jan 2020

Fingerprint

Northern Ireland
Latin America
Names
citizenship
regime
human being
management
Body Remains

Keywords

  • forensics
  • disappearance
  • Latin America
  • transitional justice

Cite this

@article{e00eb97b967b4946ac68ae0db5a04e58,
title = "The Reemergence of the Disappeared, the Role of Remains, and the ‘Forensic Gaze’",
abstract = "This paper explores what happens when the disappeared, reappear; considering how efforts to discovery and identify physical bodies are received, and what impact they have in exorcising the ghosts of the past. It discusses, following Gatti, the range of “catastrophes” that disappearance provokes, suggesting that reappearance, whether of living persons or human remains, can also lead to catastrophe. The piece argues that ‘civic management’ of disappearance creates a problematic new form of ‘citizenship’, paradoxically conferring special status that those disappeared were rarely afforded prior to their disappearance. Drawing on examples from Latin America and Northern Ireland, the piece considers how bodies without identities, like names without known destinies, disrupt social life, make claims on the living, and/or accuse perpetrators. It considers how forensic ‘truth regimes’ based on Western scientific principles sit alongside other ways of communing with the dead or disappeared.",
keywords = "forensics, disappearance, Latin America, transitional justice",
author = "Cath Collins",
year = "2020",
month = "1",
day = "1",
language = "English",
journal = "Memory Studies",
issn = "1750-6980",

}

The Reemergence of the Disappeared, the Role of Remains, and the ‘Forensic Gaze’. / Collins, Cath.

In: Memory Studies, 01.01.2020.

Research output: Contribution to journalSpecial issue

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Reemergence of the Disappeared, the Role of Remains, and the ‘Forensic Gaze’

AU - Collins, Cath

PY - 2020/1/1

Y1 - 2020/1/1

N2 - This paper explores what happens when the disappeared, reappear; considering how efforts to discovery and identify physical bodies are received, and what impact they have in exorcising the ghosts of the past. It discusses, following Gatti, the range of “catastrophes” that disappearance provokes, suggesting that reappearance, whether of living persons or human remains, can also lead to catastrophe. The piece argues that ‘civic management’ of disappearance creates a problematic new form of ‘citizenship’, paradoxically conferring special status that those disappeared were rarely afforded prior to their disappearance. Drawing on examples from Latin America and Northern Ireland, the piece considers how bodies without identities, like names without known destinies, disrupt social life, make claims on the living, and/or accuse perpetrators. It considers how forensic ‘truth regimes’ based on Western scientific principles sit alongside other ways of communing with the dead or disappeared.

AB - This paper explores what happens when the disappeared, reappear; considering how efforts to discovery and identify physical bodies are received, and what impact they have in exorcising the ghosts of the past. It discusses, following Gatti, the range of “catastrophes” that disappearance provokes, suggesting that reappearance, whether of living persons or human remains, can also lead to catastrophe. The piece argues that ‘civic management’ of disappearance creates a problematic new form of ‘citizenship’, paradoxically conferring special status that those disappeared were rarely afforded prior to their disappearance. Drawing on examples from Latin America and Northern Ireland, the piece considers how bodies without identities, like names without known destinies, disrupt social life, make claims on the living, and/or accuse perpetrators. It considers how forensic ‘truth regimes’ based on Western scientific principles sit alongside other ways of communing with the dead or disappeared.

KW - forensics

KW - disappearance

KW - Latin America

KW - transitional justice

M3 - Special issue

JO - Memory Studies

T2 - Memory Studies

JF - Memory Studies

SN - 1750-6980

ER -