The Modified Comparable Sales Method as the Basis for a Property Tax Valuations System and its Relationship and Comparison to Spatially Autoregressive Valuation Models

Richard A. Borst, William McCluskey

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

    Abstract

    The Comparable Sales Method of Valuation (CSM) is widely used in the United States for valuing residential properties. There is an identifiable relationship between CSM as practiced by mass appraisers and the recent developments in spatially aware valuation models. A modified CSM (MCSM) is shown to be a special case of a spatially lagged weight matrix model. There is a less formal but clear relationship with Geographically Weighted Regression as well. The predictive accuracy of the CSM and MCSM are compared to several Ordinary Least Squares Model configurations, and results obtained from Geographically Weighted Regression via empirical studies on diverse datasets. An example of a comparable sales weighting scheme as practiced by mass appraisers is provided. In addition, particular interest is focused on how well each method is able to model the spatial variations in property values. This is done by examining the spatial autocorrelation in residual errors of the predicted values.
    LanguageEnglish
    Title of host publicationMass Appraisal Methods: An International Perspective for Property Valuers
    EditorsTom Kauko, Maurizio d'Amato
    Pages49-69
    Publication statusPublished - 2008

    Fingerprint

    valuation
    autocorrelation
    spatial variation
    comparison
    method
    tax
    matrix

    Cite this

    Borst, R. A., & McCluskey, W. (2008). The Modified Comparable Sales Method as the Basis for a Property Tax Valuations System and its Relationship and Comparison to Spatially Autoregressive Valuation Models. In T. Kauko, & M. d'Amato (Eds.), Mass Appraisal Methods: An International Perspective for Property Valuers (pp. 49-69)
    Borst, Richard A. ; McCluskey, William. / The Modified Comparable Sales Method as the Basis for a Property Tax Valuations System and its Relationship and Comparison to Spatially Autoregressive Valuation Models. Mass Appraisal Methods: An International Perspective for Property Valuers. editor / Tom Kauko ; Maurizio d'Amato. 2008. pp. 49-69
    @inbook{4d903e59c095486895b8588a6a71b5b3,
    title = "The Modified Comparable Sales Method as the Basis for a Property Tax Valuations System and its Relationship and Comparison to Spatially Autoregressive Valuation Models",
    abstract = "The Comparable Sales Method of Valuation (CSM) is widely used in the United States for valuing residential properties. There is an identifiable relationship between CSM as practiced by mass appraisers and the recent developments in spatially aware valuation models. A modified CSM (MCSM) is shown to be a special case of a spatially lagged weight matrix model. There is a less formal but clear relationship with Geographically Weighted Regression as well. The predictive accuracy of the CSM and MCSM are compared to several Ordinary Least Squares Model configurations, and results obtained from Geographically Weighted Regression via empirical studies on diverse datasets. An example of a comparable sales weighting scheme as practiced by mass appraisers is provided. In addition, particular interest is focused on how well each method is able to model the spatial variations in property values. This is done by examining the spatial autocorrelation in residual errors of the predicted values.",
    author = "Borst, {Richard A.} and William McCluskey",
    year = "2008",
    language = "English",
    isbn = "1-4051-8097-8",
    pages = "49--69",
    editor = "Tom Kauko and Maurizio d'Amato",
    booktitle = "Mass Appraisal Methods: An International Perspective for Property Valuers",

    }

    Borst, RA & McCluskey, W 2008, The Modified Comparable Sales Method as the Basis for a Property Tax Valuations System and its Relationship and Comparison to Spatially Autoregressive Valuation Models. in T Kauko & M d'Amato (eds), Mass Appraisal Methods: An International Perspective for Property Valuers. pp. 49-69.

    The Modified Comparable Sales Method as the Basis for a Property Tax Valuations System and its Relationship and Comparison to Spatially Autoregressive Valuation Models. / Borst, Richard A.; McCluskey, William.

    Mass Appraisal Methods: An International Perspective for Property Valuers. ed. / Tom Kauko; Maurizio d'Amato. 2008. p. 49-69.

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

    TY - CHAP

    T1 - The Modified Comparable Sales Method as the Basis for a Property Tax Valuations System and its Relationship and Comparison to Spatially Autoregressive Valuation Models

    AU - Borst, Richard A.

    AU - McCluskey, William

    PY - 2008

    Y1 - 2008

    N2 - The Comparable Sales Method of Valuation (CSM) is widely used in the United States for valuing residential properties. There is an identifiable relationship between CSM as practiced by mass appraisers and the recent developments in spatially aware valuation models. A modified CSM (MCSM) is shown to be a special case of a spatially lagged weight matrix model. There is a less formal but clear relationship with Geographically Weighted Regression as well. The predictive accuracy of the CSM and MCSM are compared to several Ordinary Least Squares Model configurations, and results obtained from Geographically Weighted Regression via empirical studies on diverse datasets. An example of a comparable sales weighting scheme as practiced by mass appraisers is provided. In addition, particular interest is focused on how well each method is able to model the spatial variations in property values. This is done by examining the spatial autocorrelation in residual errors of the predicted values.

    AB - The Comparable Sales Method of Valuation (CSM) is widely used in the United States for valuing residential properties. There is an identifiable relationship between CSM as practiced by mass appraisers and the recent developments in spatially aware valuation models. A modified CSM (MCSM) is shown to be a special case of a spatially lagged weight matrix model. There is a less formal but clear relationship with Geographically Weighted Regression as well. The predictive accuracy of the CSM and MCSM are compared to several Ordinary Least Squares Model configurations, and results obtained from Geographically Weighted Regression via empirical studies on diverse datasets. An example of a comparable sales weighting scheme as practiced by mass appraisers is provided. In addition, particular interest is focused on how well each method is able to model the spatial variations in property values. This is done by examining the spatial autocorrelation in residual errors of the predicted values.

    M3 - Chapter

    SN - 1-4051-8097-8

    SP - 49

    EP - 69

    BT - Mass Appraisal Methods: An International Perspective for Property Valuers

    A2 - Kauko, Tom

    A2 - d'Amato, Maurizio

    ER -

    Borst RA, McCluskey W. The Modified Comparable Sales Method as the Basis for a Property Tax Valuations System and its Relationship and Comparison to Spatially Autoregressive Valuation Models. In Kauko T, d'Amato M, editors, Mass Appraisal Methods: An International Perspective for Property Valuers. 2008. p. 49-69