The Law of Proportionate Effect: The Growth of the UK Credit Union Movement at National and Regional Level.

Anne Marie Ward, Donal G. McKillop

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

11 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This study examines credit union size-growth relationships within the context of Gibrat’s law of proportionate effect. This relates to the hypothesis that the growth of each firm in each period is random. The analysis covers the period 1994 to 2000 and is undertaken separately for the United Kingdom (UK) and its regions, Northern Ireland, England & Wales and Scotland. Sample attrition is a characteristic of the data and to avoid the problem of survivorship bias the inverse of the Mill’s ratio, obtained from a probit regression for surviving credit unions, is introduced into the estimating relationship. In terms of the empirical results, little evidence emerged to support the law of proportionate effect as a theoretical paradigm. Although not universal, three broad findings emerged. First, small credit unions on average grow faster than their larger counterparts, although there was also some evidence of non-linearity in this relationship. Secondly, growth persistence pertained with credit unions which experienced above average growth (below average growth) in one period, experiencing above average growth (below average growth) in the next. Thirdly, variability of growth was not independent of size with the cross-sectional variance of the error term inversely related to size suggesting that small credit unions have greater growth variability than larger ones.
LanguageEnglish
Pages1827-1859
JournalJournal of Business Finance and Accounting
Volume32
Issue number9 & 10
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 31 Dec 2005

Fingerprint

Credit unions
Paradigm
Attrition
Northern Ireland
Probit regression
Wales
Empirical results
Persistence
England
Survivorship bias
Nonlinearity
Scotland

Keywords

  • credit unions
  • law of proportionate effect
  • Gibrat's law
  • Industry growth

Cite this

@article{11e0329968b64e4096763fc1ddf68493,
title = "The Law of Proportionate Effect: The Growth of the UK Credit Union Movement at National and Regional Level.",
abstract = "This study examines credit union size-growth relationships within the context of Gibrat’s law of proportionate effect. This relates to the hypothesis that the growth of each firm in each period is random. The analysis covers the period 1994 to 2000 and is undertaken separately for the United Kingdom (UK) and its regions, Northern Ireland, England & Wales and Scotland. Sample attrition is a characteristic of the data and to avoid the problem of survivorship bias the inverse of the Mill’s ratio, obtained from a probit regression for surviving credit unions, is introduced into the estimating relationship. In terms of the empirical results, little evidence emerged to support the law of proportionate effect as a theoretical paradigm. Although not universal, three broad findings emerged. First, small credit unions on average grow faster than their larger counterparts, although there was also some evidence of non-linearity in this relationship. Secondly, growth persistence pertained with credit unions which experienced above average growth (below average growth) in one period, experiencing above average growth (below average growth) in the next. Thirdly, variability of growth was not independent of size with the cross-sectional variance of the error term inversely related to size suggesting that small credit unions have greater growth variability than larger ones.",
keywords = "credit unions, law of proportionate effect, Gibrat's law, Industry growth",
author = "Ward, {Anne Marie} and McKillop, {Donal G.}",
year = "2005",
month = "12",
day = "31",
doi = "10.1111/j.0306-686X.2005.00649.x",
language = "English",
volume = "32",
pages = "1827--1859",
journal = "Journal of Business Finance and Accounting",
issn = "0306-686X",
number = "9 & 10",

}

The Law of Proportionate Effect: The Growth of the UK Credit Union Movement at National and Regional Level. / Ward, Anne Marie; McKillop, Donal G.

In: Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, Vol. 32, No. 9 & 10, 31.12.2005, p. 1827-1859.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Law of Proportionate Effect: The Growth of the UK Credit Union Movement at National and Regional Level.

AU - Ward, Anne Marie

AU - McKillop, Donal G.

PY - 2005/12/31

Y1 - 2005/12/31

N2 - This study examines credit union size-growth relationships within the context of Gibrat’s law of proportionate effect. This relates to the hypothesis that the growth of each firm in each period is random. The analysis covers the period 1994 to 2000 and is undertaken separately for the United Kingdom (UK) and its regions, Northern Ireland, England & Wales and Scotland. Sample attrition is a characteristic of the data and to avoid the problem of survivorship bias the inverse of the Mill’s ratio, obtained from a probit regression for surviving credit unions, is introduced into the estimating relationship. In terms of the empirical results, little evidence emerged to support the law of proportionate effect as a theoretical paradigm. Although not universal, three broad findings emerged. First, small credit unions on average grow faster than their larger counterparts, although there was also some evidence of non-linearity in this relationship. Secondly, growth persistence pertained with credit unions which experienced above average growth (below average growth) in one period, experiencing above average growth (below average growth) in the next. Thirdly, variability of growth was not independent of size with the cross-sectional variance of the error term inversely related to size suggesting that small credit unions have greater growth variability than larger ones.

AB - This study examines credit union size-growth relationships within the context of Gibrat’s law of proportionate effect. This relates to the hypothesis that the growth of each firm in each period is random. The analysis covers the period 1994 to 2000 and is undertaken separately for the United Kingdom (UK) and its regions, Northern Ireland, England & Wales and Scotland. Sample attrition is a characteristic of the data and to avoid the problem of survivorship bias the inverse of the Mill’s ratio, obtained from a probit regression for surviving credit unions, is introduced into the estimating relationship. In terms of the empirical results, little evidence emerged to support the law of proportionate effect as a theoretical paradigm. Although not universal, three broad findings emerged. First, small credit unions on average grow faster than their larger counterparts, although there was also some evidence of non-linearity in this relationship. Secondly, growth persistence pertained with credit unions which experienced above average growth (below average growth) in one period, experiencing above average growth (below average growth) in the next. Thirdly, variability of growth was not independent of size with the cross-sectional variance of the error term inversely related to size suggesting that small credit unions have greater growth variability than larger ones.

KW - credit unions

KW - law of proportionate effect

KW - Gibrat's law

KW - Industry growth

U2 - 10.1111/j.0306-686X.2005.00649.x

DO - 10.1111/j.0306-686X.2005.00649.x

M3 - Article

VL - 32

SP - 1827

EP - 1859

JO - Journal of Business Finance and Accounting

T2 - Journal of Business Finance and Accounting

JF - Journal of Business Finance and Accounting

SN - 0306-686X

IS - 9 & 10

ER -