The Elephant in the Room: Dealing with an Unprosecuted Criminal Disclosure in a Therapeutic Setting

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Aims: The present study sought to explore the ethical and legal challenges faced by therapists following a client's disclosure of an unprosecuted criminal offence during therapy.
Methods: A questionnaire was developed to collect demographic information, to investigate therapists' levels of legal knowledge; and to identify reporting behavior following a client's disclosure of a past crime through eight
hypothetical scenarios. Four semi-structured interviews were carried out using the hypothetical scenarios to explore the decision making process in further depth.
Results: The findings highlighted that just over half the respondents felt they were not adequately informed about their legal obligations to report disclosures. Non-reporting emerged as a significant issue in the hypothetical
scenarios. Further analysis highlighted that reporters tended to have greater legal knowledge and increased training levels but had higher levels of discomfort in making the decision to report.
Discussion: The findings suggested that respondents are aware of their legal duty to report but in practice do not follow through on this duty. A significant number of social, therapeutic and personal factors impacted on the decision
making process such as the crime; the impact on therapy; the client's disclosure; legal obligation; and personal characteristics of the therapist.
LanguageEnglish
Pages1-8
JournalJournal of Forensic Psychology
Volume1
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 30 Nov 2016

Fingerprint

therapist
offense
obligation
scenario
reporter
decision making process
questionnaire
interview

Keywords

  • Ethical dilemma
  • Unprosecuted criminal offence
  • Mandatory reporting
  • Disclosures

Cite this

@article{e3cd88d7200c4ab084f7c2d463a682ab,
title = "The Elephant in the Room: Dealing with an Unprosecuted Criminal Disclosure in a Therapeutic Setting",
abstract = "Aims: The present study sought to explore the ethical and legal challenges faced by therapists following a client's disclosure of an unprosecuted criminal offence during therapy.Methods: A questionnaire was developed to collect demographic information, to investigate therapists' levels of legal knowledge; and to identify reporting behavior following a client's disclosure of a past crime through eighthypothetical scenarios. Four semi-structured interviews were carried out using the hypothetical scenarios to explore the decision making process in further depth.Results: The findings highlighted that just over half the respondents felt they were not adequately informed about their legal obligations to report disclosures. Non-reporting emerged as a significant issue in the hypotheticalscenarios. Further analysis highlighted that reporters tended to have greater legal knowledge and increased training levels but had higher levels of discomfort in making the decision to report.Discussion: The findings suggested that respondents are aware of their legal duty to report but in practice do not follow through on this duty. A significant number of social, therapeutic and personal factors impacted on the decisionmaking process such as the crime; the impact on therapy; the client's disclosure; legal obligation; and personal characteristics of the therapist.",
keywords = "Ethical dilemma, Unprosecuted criminal offence, Mandatory reporting, Disclosures",
author = "Jean Daly-Lynn and Clare Daly and Catrin Rhys",
year = "2016",
month = "11",
day = "30",
doi = "10.4172/2475-319X.1000114",
language = "English",
volume = "1",
pages = "1--8",
journal = "Journal of Forensic Psychology",
issn = "2475-319X",
number = "4",

}

The Elephant in the Room: Dealing with an Unprosecuted Criminal Disclosure in a Therapeutic Setting. / Daly-Lynn, Jean; Daly, Clare; Rhys, Catrin.

In: Journal of Forensic Psychology, Vol. 1, No. 4, 30.11.2016, p. 1-8.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Elephant in the Room: Dealing with an Unprosecuted Criminal Disclosure in a Therapeutic Setting

AU - Daly-Lynn, Jean

AU - Daly, Clare

AU - Rhys, Catrin

PY - 2016/11/30

Y1 - 2016/11/30

N2 - Aims: The present study sought to explore the ethical and legal challenges faced by therapists following a client's disclosure of an unprosecuted criminal offence during therapy.Methods: A questionnaire was developed to collect demographic information, to investigate therapists' levels of legal knowledge; and to identify reporting behavior following a client's disclosure of a past crime through eighthypothetical scenarios. Four semi-structured interviews were carried out using the hypothetical scenarios to explore the decision making process in further depth.Results: The findings highlighted that just over half the respondents felt they were not adequately informed about their legal obligations to report disclosures. Non-reporting emerged as a significant issue in the hypotheticalscenarios. Further analysis highlighted that reporters tended to have greater legal knowledge and increased training levels but had higher levels of discomfort in making the decision to report.Discussion: The findings suggested that respondents are aware of their legal duty to report but in practice do not follow through on this duty. A significant number of social, therapeutic and personal factors impacted on the decisionmaking process such as the crime; the impact on therapy; the client's disclosure; legal obligation; and personal characteristics of the therapist.

AB - Aims: The present study sought to explore the ethical and legal challenges faced by therapists following a client's disclosure of an unprosecuted criminal offence during therapy.Methods: A questionnaire was developed to collect demographic information, to investigate therapists' levels of legal knowledge; and to identify reporting behavior following a client's disclosure of a past crime through eighthypothetical scenarios. Four semi-structured interviews were carried out using the hypothetical scenarios to explore the decision making process in further depth.Results: The findings highlighted that just over half the respondents felt they were not adequately informed about their legal obligations to report disclosures. Non-reporting emerged as a significant issue in the hypotheticalscenarios. Further analysis highlighted that reporters tended to have greater legal knowledge and increased training levels but had higher levels of discomfort in making the decision to report.Discussion: The findings suggested that respondents are aware of their legal duty to report but in practice do not follow through on this duty. A significant number of social, therapeutic and personal factors impacted on the decisionmaking process such as the crime; the impact on therapy; the client's disclosure; legal obligation; and personal characteristics of the therapist.

KW - Ethical dilemma

KW - Unprosecuted criminal offence

KW - Mandatory reporting

KW - Disclosures

U2 - 10.4172/2475-319X.1000114

DO - 10.4172/2475-319X.1000114

M3 - Article

VL - 1

SP - 1

EP - 8

JO - Journal of Forensic Psychology

T2 - Journal of Forensic Psychology

JF - Journal of Forensic Psychology

SN - 2475-319X

IS - 4

ER -