The Agreement and devolved social security: a missed opportunity for socio-economic rights in Northern Ireland?

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The UK government makes three key human rights-related commitments in the Good Friday Agreement, the basis for the restoration of devolution and transition from conflict to peace in Northern Ireland: incorporate the European Convention on Human Rights into Northern Ireland law, consider proposals for a regional Bill of Rights and ensure compliance with the state’s international obligations in the region. While ECHR compliance is required of devolved institutions by the constitutional legislation, the prospects of a Bill of Rights being enacted appear limited and oversight of compliance with other international obligations is unsatisfactorily placed in political, rather than judicial, hands. Consequently, protection of socio-economic rights beyond those covered by ECHR is weak. This paper argues that judicial protection of socio-economic rights – whether in the form of a Bill of Rights or the incorporation of additional human rights agreements into Northern Ireland law – is required for full implementation of the Agreement. It then considers the implications of such a step for social security in the region. The concluding section highlights political and fiscal implications that would have to be considered.
LanguageEnglish
Pages105-126
JournalNorthern Ireland Legal Quarterly
Volume66
Issue number2
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 17 Mar 2015

Fingerprint

ECHR
social security
bill
obligation
human rights
economics
Law
restoration
decentralization
peace
legislation
commitment

Keywords

  • Good Friday Agreement
  • Devolution
  • Social Security
  • Social and economic rights

Cite this

@article{cb776e8fbb264c9bb3f9c5b5b81aab47,
title = "The Agreement and devolved social security: a missed opportunity for socio-economic rights in Northern Ireland?",
abstract = "The UK government makes three key human rights-related commitments in the Good Friday Agreement, the basis for the restoration of devolution and transition from conflict to peace in Northern Ireland: incorporate the European Convention on Human Rights into Northern Ireland law, consider proposals for a regional Bill of Rights and ensure compliance with the state’s international obligations in the region. While ECHR compliance is required of devolved institutions by the constitutional legislation, the prospects of a Bill of Rights being enacted appear limited and oversight of compliance with other international obligations is unsatisfactorily placed in political, rather than judicial, hands. Consequently, protection of socio-economic rights beyond those covered by ECHR is weak. This paper argues that judicial protection of socio-economic rights – whether in the form of a Bill of Rights or the incorporation of additional human rights agreements into Northern Ireland law – is required for full implementation of the Agreement. It then considers the implications of such a step for social security in the region. The concluding section highlights political and fiscal implications that would have to be considered.",
keywords = "Good Friday Agreement, Devolution, Social Security, Social and economic rights",
author = "Mark Simpson",
note = "Research supervised by Grainne McKeever and Ann Marie Gray",
year = "2015",
month = "3",
day = "17",
language = "English",
volume = "66",
pages = "105--126",
journal = "Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly",
issn = "0029-3105",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Agreement and devolved social security: a missed opportunity for socio-economic rights in Northern Ireland?

AU - Simpson, Mark

N1 - Research supervised by Grainne McKeever and Ann Marie Gray

PY - 2015/3/17

Y1 - 2015/3/17

N2 - The UK government makes three key human rights-related commitments in the Good Friday Agreement, the basis for the restoration of devolution and transition from conflict to peace in Northern Ireland: incorporate the European Convention on Human Rights into Northern Ireland law, consider proposals for a regional Bill of Rights and ensure compliance with the state’s international obligations in the region. While ECHR compliance is required of devolved institutions by the constitutional legislation, the prospects of a Bill of Rights being enacted appear limited and oversight of compliance with other international obligations is unsatisfactorily placed in political, rather than judicial, hands. Consequently, protection of socio-economic rights beyond those covered by ECHR is weak. This paper argues that judicial protection of socio-economic rights – whether in the form of a Bill of Rights or the incorporation of additional human rights agreements into Northern Ireland law – is required for full implementation of the Agreement. It then considers the implications of such a step for social security in the region. The concluding section highlights political and fiscal implications that would have to be considered.

AB - The UK government makes three key human rights-related commitments in the Good Friday Agreement, the basis for the restoration of devolution and transition from conflict to peace in Northern Ireland: incorporate the European Convention on Human Rights into Northern Ireland law, consider proposals for a regional Bill of Rights and ensure compliance with the state’s international obligations in the region. While ECHR compliance is required of devolved institutions by the constitutional legislation, the prospects of a Bill of Rights being enacted appear limited and oversight of compliance with other international obligations is unsatisfactorily placed in political, rather than judicial, hands. Consequently, protection of socio-economic rights beyond those covered by ECHR is weak. This paper argues that judicial protection of socio-economic rights – whether in the form of a Bill of Rights or the incorporation of additional human rights agreements into Northern Ireland law – is required for full implementation of the Agreement. It then considers the implications of such a step for social security in the region. The concluding section highlights political and fiscal implications that would have to be considered.

KW - Good Friday Agreement

KW - Devolution

KW - Social Security

KW - Social and economic rights

M3 - Article

VL - 66

SP - 105

EP - 126

JO - Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly

T2 - Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly

JF - Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly

SN - 0029-3105

IS - 2

ER -