Telling the Story: Meaning making in a community narrative

Karyn Stapleton, John Wilson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Narrative theory distinguishes between the theme of a story and its form or “telling”. This idea is central to Narrative Psychology, where narrative is proposed as a way of understanding cognition (Bruner,1986, 2004) and the concept of narrative templates (Wertsch, 2002) is used to explain underlying regularities in how collective memories/accounts are structured and expressed. Linguistic studies of narrative have mostly examined “one-off” tellings, focusing on structural or social features, with a related concern to define narrative discourse per se. Consequently, there is little empirical examination of how shared templates are realised in different settings, nor of how such templates structure everyday understanding within communities. Here, we examine two separate tellings of a political/community narrative in a Belfast nationalist community. Both draw upon a shared narrative template, which links sense-making and identity at different levels within the community. However, there are marked performative differences between the two tellings. Our analysis is distinctive in focusing on a shared narrative template in two settings rather than on self-contained narrative. We highlight three key points relevant to narrative pragmatics. Firstly, we show how community narrative operates as a shared sense-making resource for members. Secondly, we demonstrate that different discourse activities are used to realise the underlying template, and hence, we argue against seeking definitive descriptions of “narrative discourse”. Finally, we show how the narrative performances reflect power and the perceived purpose of the respective interviews, thereby providing a framework for identity positioning.
LanguageEnglish
Pages60-80
Number of pages20
JournalJournal of Pragmatics
Volume108
Early online date5 Jan 2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 31 Jan 2017

Fingerprint

narrative
community
discourse
collective memory
regularity
cognition
pragmatics
psychology
linguistics
examination
interview
resources

Keywords

  • Narrative templates
  • narrative performance
  • community narrative
  • political narrative
  • meaning/sense-making
  • narrative discourse

Cite this

@article{91191f5bc656441c89b971933983f252,
title = "Telling the Story: Meaning making in a community narrative",
abstract = "Narrative theory distinguishes between the theme of a story and its form or “telling”. This idea is central to Narrative Psychology, where narrative is proposed as a way of understanding cognition (Bruner,1986, 2004) and the concept of narrative templates (Wertsch, 2002) is used to explain underlying regularities in how collective memories/accounts are structured and expressed. Linguistic studies of narrative have mostly examined “one-off” tellings, focusing on structural or social features, with a related concern to define narrative discourse per se. Consequently, there is little empirical examination of how shared templates are realised in different settings, nor of how such templates structure everyday understanding within communities. Here, we examine two separate tellings of a political/community narrative in a Belfast nationalist community. Both draw upon a shared narrative template, which links sense-making and identity at different levels within the community. However, there are marked performative differences between the two tellings. Our analysis is distinctive in focusing on a shared narrative template in two settings rather than on self-contained narrative. We highlight three key points relevant to narrative pragmatics. Firstly, we show how community narrative operates as a shared sense-making resource for members. Secondly, we demonstrate that different discourse activities are used to realise the underlying template, and hence, we argue against seeking definitive descriptions of “narrative discourse”. Finally, we show how the narrative performances reflect power and the perceived purpose of the respective interviews, thereby providing a framework for identity positioning.",
keywords = "Narrative templates, narrative performance, community narrative, political narrative, meaning/sense-making, narrative discourse",
author = "Karyn Stapleton and John Wilson",
note = "Funder: ESRC",
year = "2017",
month = "1",
day = "31",
doi = "10.1016/j.pragma.2016.11.003",
language = "English",
volume = "108",
pages = "60--80",

}

Telling the Story: Meaning making in a community narrative. / Stapleton, Karyn; Wilson, John.

Vol. 108, 31.01.2017, p. 60-80.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Telling the Story: Meaning making in a community narrative

AU - Stapleton, Karyn

AU - Wilson, John

N1 - Funder: ESRC

PY - 2017/1/31

Y1 - 2017/1/31

N2 - Narrative theory distinguishes between the theme of a story and its form or “telling”. This idea is central to Narrative Psychology, where narrative is proposed as a way of understanding cognition (Bruner,1986, 2004) and the concept of narrative templates (Wertsch, 2002) is used to explain underlying regularities in how collective memories/accounts are structured and expressed. Linguistic studies of narrative have mostly examined “one-off” tellings, focusing on structural or social features, with a related concern to define narrative discourse per se. Consequently, there is little empirical examination of how shared templates are realised in different settings, nor of how such templates structure everyday understanding within communities. Here, we examine two separate tellings of a political/community narrative in a Belfast nationalist community. Both draw upon a shared narrative template, which links sense-making and identity at different levels within the community. However, there are marked performative differences between the two tellings. Our analysis is distinctive in focusing on a shared narrative template in two settings rather than on self-contained narrative. We highlight three key points relevant to narrative pragmatics. Firstly, we show how community narrative operates as a shared sense-making resource for members. Secondly, we demonstrate that different discourse activities are used to realise the underlying template, and hence, we argue against seeking definitive descriptions of “narrative discourse”. Finally, we show how the narrative performances reflect power and the perceived purpose of the respective interviews, thereby providing a framework for identity positioning.

AB - Narrative theory distinguishes between the theme of a story and its form or “telling”. This idea is central to Narrative Psychology, where narrative is proposed as a way of understanding cognition (Bruner,1986, 2004) and the concept of narrative templates (Wertsch, 2002) is used to explain underlying regularities in how collective memories/accounts are structured and expressed. Linguistic studies of narrative have mostly examined “one-off” tellings, focusing on structural or social features, with a related concern to define narrative discourse per se. Consequently, there is little empirical examination of how shared templates are realised in different settings, nor of how such templates structure everyday understanding within communities. Here, we examine two separate tellings of a political/community narrative in a Belfast nationalist community. Both draw upon a shared narrative template, which links sense-making and identity at different levels within the community. However, there are marked performative differences between the two tellings. Our analysis is distinctive in focusing on a shared narrative template in two settings rather than on self-contained narrative. We highlight three key points relevant to narrative pragmatics. Firstly, we show how community narrative operates as a shared sense-making resource for members. Secondly, we demonstrate that different discourse activities are used to realise the underlying template, and hence, we argue against seeking definitive descriptions of “narrative discourse”. Finally, we show how the narrative performances reflect power and the perceived purpose of the respective interviews, thereby providing a framework for identity positioning.

KW - Narrative templates

KW - narrative performance

KW - community narrative

KW - political narrative

KW - meaning/sense-making

KW - narrative discourse

UR - http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

U2 - 10.1016/j.pragma.2016.11.003

DO - 10.1016/j.pragma.2016.11.003

M3 - Article

VL - 108

SP - 60

EP - 80

ER -