Survivor perspectives of change processes in their domestically-violent partner: Systematic narrative review

Tony McGinn, Brian J Taylor, Mary McColgan

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

More effective work with perpetrators of intimate partner violence (IPV) can be built upon a betterunderstanding of how and why they change their behaviour. This article presents a systematicnarrative review of female IPV survivor perspectives on the changes brought about by IPV perpetrator programmes. Fourteen databases and web search engines were searched and sixteen articles reporting relevant qualitative findings were identified. Survivors often reported some level of positive change through their partner’s engagement with a programme, but the sustainability of this change is unclear and there was also some negative feedback. From the survivors’ perspective key barriers to perpetrator change include alcohol dependency, mental health challenges, relationship dynamics and their family of origin. Mechanisms by which perpetrators are held to account, namely survivor validation and judicial measures, were seen as central to the change process. Survivors perceived changes in perpetrator behaviour (the use of conflict interruption techniques and new communication skills) and changes in perpetrators’ belief systems (adopting new perspectives). Changes in belief systems were associated with more complete desistence from violence, and would appear more difficult to effect. The review highlights the complexity in this field, which is discussed by the authors with reference to practice, policy and research.
LanguageEnglish
Pages239-255
JournalTrauma, Violence, and Abuse
Volume17
Early online date11 May 2015
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2016

Fingerprint

Survivors
violence
narrative
Search Engine
communication skills
search engine
Family Relations
Program Evaluation
Violence
mental health
alcohol
sustainability
Mental Health
Communication
Alcohols
Databases
Research
Intimate Partner Violence

Keywords

  • domestic violence
  • batterer
  • intervention/treatment
  • change processes
  • behaviour change

Cite this

@article{3864b5efa74a4dd7b978bb330945444a,
title = "Survivor perspectives of change processes in their domestically-violent partner: Systematic narrative review",
abstract = "More effective work with perpetrators of intimate partner violence (IPV) can be built upon a betterunderstanding of how and why they change their behaviour. This article presents a systematicnarrative review of female IPV survivor perspectives on the changes brought about by IPV perpetrator programmes. Fourteen databases and web search engines were searched and sixteen articles reporting relevant qualitative findings were identified. Survivors often reported some level of positive change through their partner’s engagement with a programme, but the sustainability of this change is unclear and there was also some negative feedback. From the survivors’ perspective key barriers to perpetrator change include alcohol dependency, mental health challenges, relationship dynamics and their family of origin. Mechanisms by which perpetrators are held to account, namely survivor validation and judicial measures, were seen as central to the change process. Survivors perceived changes in perpetrator behaviour (the use of conflict interruption techniques and new communication skills) and changes in perpetrators’ belief systems (adopting new perspectives). Changes in belief systems were associated with more complete desistence from violence, and would appear more difficult to effect. The review highlights the complexity in this field, which is discussed by the authors with reference to practice, policy and research.",
keywords = "domestic violence, batterer, intervention/treatment, change processes, behaviour change",
author = "Tony McGinn and Taylor, {Brian J} and Mary McColgan",
year = "2016",
month = "7",
doi = "10.1177/1524838015584358",
language = "English",
volume = "17",
pages = "239--255",
journal = "Trauma, Violence, and Abuse",
issn = "1524-8380",

}

Survivor perspectives of change processes in their domestically-violent partner: Systematic narrative review. / McGinn, Tony; Taylor, Brian J; McColgan, Mary.

In: Trauma, Violence, and Abuse, Vol. 17, 07.2016, p. 239-255.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Survivor perspectives of change processes in their domestically-violent partner: Systematic narrative review

AU - McGinn, Tony

AU - Taylor, Brian J

AU - McColgan, Mary

PY - 2016/7

Y1 - 2016/7

N2 - More effective work with perpetrators of intimate partner violence (IPV) can be built upon a betterunderstanding of how and why they change their behaviour. This article presents a systematicnarrative review of female IPV survivor perspectives on the changes brought about by IPV perpetrator programmes. Fourteen databases and web search engines were searched and sixteen articles reporting relevant qualitative findings were identified. Survivors often reported some level of positive change through their partner’s engagement with a programme, but the sustainability of this change is unclear and there was also some negative feedback. From the survivors’ perspective key barriers to perpetrator change include alcohol dependency, mental health challenges, relationship dynamics and their family of origin. Mechanisms by which perpetrators are held to account, namely survivor validation and judicial measures, were seen as central to the change process. Survivors perceived changes in perpetrator behaviour (the use of conflict interruption techniques and new communication skills) and changes in perpetrators’ belief systems (adopting new perspectives). Changes in belief systems were associated with more complete desistence from violence, and would appear more difficult to effect. The review highlights the complexity in this field, which is discussed by the authors with reference to practice, policy and research.

AB - More effective work with perpetrators of intimate partner violence (IPV) can be built upon a betterunderstanding of how and why they change their behaviour. This article presents a systematicnarrative review of female IPV survivor perspectives on the changes brought about by IPV perpetrator programmes. Fourteen databases and web search engines were searched and sixteen articles reporting relevant qualitative findings were identified. Survivors often reported some level of positive change through their partner’s engagement with a programme, but the sustainability of this change is unclear and there was also some negative feedback. From the survivors’ perspective key barriers to perpetrator change include alcohol dependency, mental health challenges, relationship dynamics and their family of origin. Mechanisms by which perpetrators are held to account, namely survivor validation and judicial measures, were seen as central to the change process. Survivors perceived changes in perpetrator behaviour (the use of conflict interruption techniques and new communication skills) and changes in perpetrators’ belief systems (adopting new perspectives). Changes in belief systems were associated with more complete desistence from violence, and would appear more difficult to effect. The review highlights the complexity in this field, which is discussed by the authors with reference to practice, policy and research.

KW - domestic violence

KW - batterer

KW - intervention/treatment

KW - change processes

KW - behaviour change

U2 - 10.1177/1524838015584358

DO - 10.1177/1524838015584358

M3 - Article

VL - 17

SP - 239

EP - 255

JO - Trauma, Violence, and Abuse

T2 - Trauma, Violence, and Abuse

JF - Trauma, Violence, and Abuse

SN - 1524-8380

ER -