Performance management and the outsourcing process Lessons from a financial services organisation

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

32 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Purpose - The purpose of this paper is to assess the applicability of a number of performance management techniques in the outsourcing process, in a business services context. Design/methodology/approach - Using a structured outsourcing framework, performance management techniques are applied in a financial services organisation over a three-year period. A case study approach is employed to undertake the research, which involved the research team engaging directly with the Organisation throughout the outsourcing process. Findings - Applying performance management techniques in the outsourcing process is challenging in a number of areas including comparison difficulties, incomplete information and inadequate performance management systems. However, benchmarking and cost analysis are useful mechanisms for improving performance, and reducing costs via internal process redesign or outsourcing. Performance management techniques can be employed to remove inefficiencies from processes both prior to outsourcing and during the outsourcing relationship. Research limitations/implications - There are a number of limitations of the research approach including gaining full participation from the company, having access to all relevant company information and time constraints. Practical implications - The research findings highlight the implications of applying performance management techniques in a practical outsourcing setting. As well as identifying the challenges, the research highlights the value of integrating critical success factors, cost analysis, benchmarking and other performance management techniques into the outsourcing process. Originality/value - There are few studies in the literature of applying performance management techniques in the outsourcing process at an operation's level. The findings have identified the challenges and benefits of performance management techniques in the outsourcing process. The findings have highlighted the importance of operations management concepts such as performance management, operations strategy, business improvement and process re-design to services outsourcing, and the need for further research in this area by operations management scholars.
LanguageEnglish
Pages1025-1048
JournalInternational Journal of Operations & Production Management
Volume29
Issue number10
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2009

Fingerprint

Outsourcing
Benchmarking
Financial services
Service organization
Performance management
Industry
Costs
Management techniques

Cite this

@article{023c0440c3054bfc942f0022590c8ea9,
title = "Performance management and the outsourcing process Lessons from a financial services organisation",
abstract = "Purpose - The purpose of this paper is to assess the applicability of a number of performance management techniques in the outsourcing process, in a business services context. Design/methodology/approach - Using a structured outsourcing framework, performance management techniques are applied in a financial services organisation over a three-year period. A case study approach is employed to undertake the research, which involved the research team engaging directly with the Organisation throughout the outsourcing process. Findings - Applying performance management techniques in the outsourcing process is challenging in a number of areas including comparison difficulties, incomplete information and inadequate performance management systems. However, benchmarking and cost analysis are useful mechanisms for improving performance, and reducing costs via internal process redesign or outsourcing. Performance management techniques can be employed to remove inefficiencies from processes both prior to outsourcing and during the outsourcing relationship. Research limitations/implications - There are a number of limitations of the research approach including gaining full participation from the company, having access to all relevant company information and time constraints. Practical implications - The research findings highlight the implications of applying performance management techniques in a practical outsourcing setting. As well as identifying the challenges, the research highlights the value of integrating critical success factors, cost analysis, benchmarking and other performance management techniques into the outsourcing process. Originality/value - There are few studies in the literature of applying performance management techniques in the outsourcing process at an operation's level. The findings have identified the challenges and benefits of performance management techniques in the outsourcing process. The findings have highlighted the importance of operations management concepts such as performance management, operations strategy, business improvement and process re-design to services outsourcing, and the need for further research in this area by operations management scholars.",
author = "Ronan McIvor and Paul Humphreys and Alan McKittrick and Anthony Wall",
year = "2009",
doi = "10.1108/01443570910993474",
language = "English",
volume = "29",
pages = "1025--1048",
journal = "International Journal of Operations and Production Management",
issn = "0144-3577",
number = "10",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Performance management and the outsourcing process Lessons from a financial services organisation

AU - McIvor, Ronan

AU - Humphreys, Paul

AU - McKittrick, Alan

AU - Wall, Anthony

PY - 2009

Y1 - 2009

N2 - Purpose - The purpose of this paper is to assess the applicability of a number of performance management techniques in the outsourcing process, in a business services context. Design/methodology/approach - Using a structured outsourcing framework, performance management techniques are applied in a financial services organisation over a three-year period. A case study approach is employed to undertake the research, which involved the research team engaging directly with the Organisation throughout the outsourcing process. Findings - Applying performance management techniques in the outsourcing process is challenging in a number of areas including comparison difficulties, incomplete information and inadequate performance management systems. However, benchmarking and cost analysis are useful mechanisms for improving performance, and reducing costs via internal process redesign or outsourcing. Performance management techniques can be employed to remove inefficiencies from processes both prior to outsourcing and during the outsourcing relationship. Research limitations/implications - There are a number of limitations of the research approach including gaining full participation from the company, having access to all relevant company information and time constraints. Practical implications - The research findings highlight the implications of applying performance management techniques in a practical outsourcing setting. As well as identifying the challenges, the research highlights the value of integrating critical success factors, cost analysis, benchmarking and other performance management techniques into the outsourcing process. Originality/value - There are few studies in the literature of applying performance management techniques in the outsourcing process at an operation's level. The findings have identified the challenges and benefits of performance management techniques in the outsourcing process. The findings have highlighted the importance of operations management concepts such as performance management, operations strategy, business improvement and process re-design to services outsourcing, and the need for further research in this area by operations management scholars.

AB - Purpose - The purpose of this paper is to assess the applicability of a number of performance management techniques in the outsourcing process, in a business services context. Design/methodology/approach - Using a structured outsourcing framework, performance management techniques are applied in a financial services organisation over a three-year period. A case study approach is employed to undertake the research, which involved the research team engaging directly with the Organisation throughout the outsourcing process. Findings - Applying performance management techniques in the outsourcing process is challenging in a number of areas including comparison difficulties, incomplete information and inadequate performance management systems. However, benchmarking and cost analysis are useful mechanisms for improving performance, and reducing costs via internal process redesign or outsourcing. Performance management techniques can be employed to remove inefficiencies from processes both prior to outsourcing and during the outsourcing relationship. Research limitations/implications - There are a number of limitations of the research approach including gaining full participation from the company, having access to all relevant company information and time constraints. Practical implications - The research findings highlight the implications of applying performance management techniques in a practical outsourcing setting. As well as identifying the challenges, the research highlights the value of integrating critical success factors, cost analysis, benchmarking and other performance management techniques into the outsourcing process. Originality/value - There are few studies in the literature of applying performance management techniques in the outsourcing process at an operation's level. The findings have identified the challenges and benefits of performance management techniques in the outsourcing process. The findings have highlighted the importance of operations management concepts such as performance management, operations strategy, business improvement and process re-design to services outsourcing, and the need for further research in this area by operations management scholars.

U2 - 10.1108/01443570910993474

DO - 10.1108/01443570910993474

M3 - Article

VL - 29

SP - 1025

EP - 1048

JO - International Journal of Operations and Production Management

T2 - International Journal of Operations and Production Management

JF - International Journal of Operations and Production Management

SN - 0144-3577

IS - 10

ER -