Origins of the Irish in Northern England: An Isonymic Analysis of Data from the 1881 Census

Malcolm Smith, Donald MacRaild

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    3 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    In the mid nineteenth century, the Irish became the largest immigrant group in Britain. Despite impressions of homogeneity delivered by the dominant historiographies, these migrants were in reality complex and changing groups whose variegated nature has been underplayed by historians. One of the reasons why the Irish tend to be lumped together as an undifferentiated mass is the lack of systematic analyses of the particular regional and provincial provenance of those who made homes in England, Wales and Scotland. Historians speculate about origins; but few have interrogated the census to provide robust assertions about where in Ireland particular migrants came from. As such, complexity and subtlety are absent. The failure of the census systematically to capture specific birthplace data offers one explanation of why this is so. The sheer difficulty of abstracting data on birthplace to arrive at meaningful quantitative perspectives provides another. This essay uses a technique from biological anthropology called Random Isonymy which enables us to substitute surname data for birthplace data in order to establish the major interregional interconnections between the two islands which are evinced in Irish migration pathways. We show that the close association between name and place in Irish culture enables robust conclusions about the provenance of migrants to be derived from surname data drawn from the digitised 1881 census. Our work suggests that names may underpin cultural transfer, and thus could help explain why particular types of Irish culture emerged in one town or region but not in another. For now, this essay's discussion is restricted to an explication upon the robustness of the method.
    LanguageEnglish
    Pages152-177
    JournalImmigrants and Minorities
    Volume27
    Issue number2/3
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 1 Jul 2009

    Fingerprint

    census
    migrant
    historian
    interconnection
    historiography
    Ireland
    anthropology
    nineteenth century
    Group
    town
    immigrant
    migration
    lack

    Cite this

    Smith, Malcolm ; MacRaild, Donald. / Origins of the Irish in Northern England: An Isonymic Analysis of Data from the 1881 Census. In: Immigrants and Minorities. 2009 ; Vol. 27, No. 2/3. pp. 152-177.
    @article{28c6021156264c10bfb0768877ef5871,
    title = "Origins of the Irish in Northern England: An Isonymic Analysis of Data from the 1881 Census",
    abstract = "In the mid nineteenth century, the Irish became the largest immigrant group in Britain. Despite impressions of homogeneity delivered by the dominant historiographies, these migrants were in reality complex and changing groups whose variegated nature has been underplayed by historians. One of the reasons why the Irish tend to be lumped together as an undifferentiated mass is the lack of systematic analyses of the particular regional and provincial provenance of those who made homes in England, Wales and Scotland. Historians speculate about origins; but few have interrogated the census to provide robust assertions about where in Ireland particular migrants came from. As such, complexity and subtlety are absent. The failure of the census systematically to capture specific birthplace data offers one explanation of why this is so. The sheer difficulty of abstracting data on birthplace to arrive at meaningful quantitative perspectives provides another. This essay uses a technique from biological anthropology called Random Isonymy which enables us to substitute surname data for birthplace data in order to establish the major interregional interconnections between the two islands which are evinced in Irish migration pathways. We show that the close association between name and place in Irish culture enables robust conclusions about the provenance of migrants to be derived from surname data drawn from the digitised 1881 census. Our work suggests that names may underpin cultural transfer, and thus could help explain why particular types of Irish culture emerged in one town or region but not in another. For now, this essay's discussion is restricted to an explication upon the robustness of the method.",
    author = "Malcolm Smith and Donald MacRaild",
    year = "2009",
    month = "7",
    day = "1",
    doi = "10.1080/02619280903128095",
    language = "English",
    volume = "27",
    pages = "152--177",
    journal = "Immigrants and Minorities",
    issn = "0261-9288",
    number = "2/3",

    }

    Origins of the Irish in Northern England: An Isonymic Analysis of Data from the 1881 Census. / Smith, Malcolm; MacRaild, Donald.

    In: Immigrants and Minorities, Vol. 27, No. 2/3, 01.07.2009, p. 152-177.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Origins of the Irish in Northern England: An Isonymic Analysis of Data from the 1881 Census

    AU - Smith, Malcolm

    AU - MacRaild, Donald

    PY - 2009/7/1

    Y1 - 2009/7/1

    N2 - In the mid nineteenth century, the Irish became the largest immigrant group in Britain. Despite impressions of homogeneity delivered by the dominant historiographies, these migrants were in reality complex and changing groups whose variegated nature has been underplayed by historians. One of the reasons why the Irish tend to be lumped together as an undifferentiated mass is the lack of systematic analyses of the particular regional and provincial provenance of those who made homes in England, Wales and Scotland. Historians speculate about origins; but few have interrogated the census to provide robust assertions about where in Ireland particular migrants came from. As such, complexity and subtlety are absent. The failure of the census systematically to capture specific birthplace data offers one explanation of why this is so. The sheer difficulty of abstracting data on birthplace to arrive at meaningful quantitative perspectives provides another. This essay uses a technique from biological anthropology called Random Isonymy which enables us to substitute surname data for birthplace data in order to establish the major interregional interconnections between the two islands which are evinced in Irish migration pathways. We show that the close association between name and place in Irish culture enables robust conclusions about the provenance of migrants to be derived from surname data drawn from the digitised 1881 census. Our work suggests that names may underpin cultural transfer, and thus could help explain why particular types of Irish culture emerged in one town or region but not in another. For now, this essay's discussion is restricted to an explication upon the robustness of the method.

    AB - In the mid nineteenth century, the Irish became the largest immigrant group in Britain. Despite impressions of homogeneity delivered by the dominant historiographies, these migrants were in reality complex and changing groups whose variegated nature has been underplayed by historians. One of the reasons why the Irish tend to be lumped together as an undifferentiated mass is the lack of systematic analyses of the particular regional and provincial provenance of those who made homes in England, Wales and Scotland. Historians speculate about origins; but few have interrogated the census to provide robust assertions about where in Ireland particular migrants came from. As such, complexity and subtlety are absent. The failure of the census systematically to capture specific birthplace data offers one explanation of why this is so. The sheer difficulty of abstracting data on birthplace to arrive at meaningful quantitative perspectives provides another. This essay uses a technique from biological anthropology called Random Isonymy which enables us to substitute surname data for birthplace data in order to establish the major interregional interconnections between the two islands which are evinced in Irish migration pathways. We show that the close association between name and place in Irish culture enables robust conclusions about the provenance of migrants to be derived from surname data drawn from the digitised 1881 census. Our work suggests that names may underpin cultural transfer, and thus could help explain why particular types of Irish culture emerged in one town or region but not in another. For now, this essay's discussion is restricted to an explication upon the robustness of the method.

    U2 - 10.1080/02619280903128095

    DO - 10.1080/02619280903128095

    M3 - Article

    VL - 27

    SP - 152

    EP - 177

    JO - Immigrants and Minorities

    T2 - Immigrants and Minorities

    JF - Immigrants and Minorities

    SN - 0261-9288

    IS - 2/3

    ER -