Nonlinear empirical modeling to estimate phosphorus exports using continuous records of turbidity and discharge

C. Minaudo, R. Dupas, C. Gascuel-Odoux, O. Fovet, P.-E. Mellander, P. Jordan, M. Shore, F. Moatar

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

10 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

We tested an empirical modeling approach using relatively low-cost continuous records of turbidity and discharge as proxies to estimate phosphorus (P) concentrations at a subhourly time step for estimating loads. The method takes into account nonlinearity and hysteresis effects during storm events, and hydrological conditions variability. High-frequency records of total P and reactive P originating from four contrasting European agricultural catchments in terms of P loads were used to test the method. The models were calibrated on weekly grab sampling data combined with 10 storms surveyed subhourly per year (weekly+ survey) and then used to reconstruct P concentrations during all storm events for computing annual loads. For total P, results showed that this modeling approach allowed the estimation of annual loads with limited uncertainties (≈ −10% ± 15%), more reliable than estimations based on simple linear regressions using turbidity, based on interpolated weekly+ data without storm event reconstruction, or on discharge weighted calculations from weekly series or monthly series. For reactive P, load uncertainties based on the nonlinear model were similar to uncertainties based on storm event reconstruction using simple linear regression (≈ 20% ± 30%), and remained lower than uncertainties obtained without storm reconstruction on weekly or monthly series, but larger than uncertainties based on interpolated weekly+ data (≈ −15% ± 20%). These empirical models showed we could estimate reliable P exports from noncontinuous P time series when using continuous proxies, and this could potentially be very useful for completing time-series data sets in high-frequency surveys, even over extended periods.
LanguageEnglish
Pages7590-7606
JournalWater Resources Research
Volume53
Issue number9
Early online date1 Sep 2017
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 1 Sep 2017

Fingerprint

turbidity
phosphorus
modeling
time series
agricultural catchment
hysteresis
nonlinearity
sampling
cost
method

Keywords

  • Phosphorus
  • non-linear empirical modelling
  • high-frequency monitoring
  • proxies
  • hysteresis

Cite this

Minaudo, C. ; Dupas, R. ; Gascuel-Odoux, C. ; Fovet, O. ; Mellander, P.-E. ; Jordan, P. ; Shore, M. ; Moatar, F. / Nonlinear empirical modeling to estimate phosphorus exports using continuous records of turbidity and discharge. In: Water Resources Research. 2017 ; Vol. 53, No. 9. pp. 7590-7606.
@article{4eeb56a091124f10accc6dac66de511d,
title = "Nonlinear empirical modeling to estimate phosphorus exports using continuous records of turbidity and discharge",
abstract = "We tested an empirical modeling approach using relatively low-cost continuous records of turbidity and discharge as proxies to estimate phosphorus (P) concentrations at a subhourly time step for estimating loads. The method takes into account nonlinearity and hysteresis effects during storm events, and hydrological conditions variability. High-frequency records of total P and reactive P originating from four contrasting European agricultural catchments in terms of P loads were used to test the method. The models were calibrated on weekly grab sampling data combined with 10 storms surveyed subhourly per year (weekly+ survey) and then used to reconstruct P concentrations during all storm events for computing annual loads. For total P, results showed that this modeling approach allowed the estimation of annual loads with limited uncertainties (≈ −10{\%} ± 15{\%}), more reliable than estimations based on simple linear regressions using turbidity, based on interpolated weekly+ data without storm event reconstruction, or on discharge weighted calculations from weekly series or monthly series. For reactive P, load uncertainties based on the nonlinear model were similar to uncertainties based on storm event reconstruction using simple linear regression (≈ 20{\%} ± 30{\%}), and remained lower than uncertainties obtained without storm reconstruction on weekly or monthly series, but larger than uncertainties based on interpolated weekly+ data (≈ −15{\%} ± 20{\%}). These empirical models showed we could estimate reliable P exports from noncontinuous P time series when using continuous proxies, and this could potentially be very useful for completing time-series data sets in high-frequency surveys, even over extended periods.",
keywords = "Phosphorus, non-linear empirical modelling, high-frequency monitoring, proxies, hysteresis",
author = "C. Minaudo and R. Dupas and C. Gascuel-Odoux and O. Fovet and P.-E. Mellander and P. Jordan and M. Shore and F. Moatar",
year = "2017",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/2017WR020590",
language = "English",
volume = "53",
pages = "7590--7606",
journal = "Water Resources Research",
issn = "0043-1397",
number = "9",

}

Minaudo, C, Dupas, R, Gascuel-Odoux, C, Fovet, O, Mellander, P-E, Jordan, P, Shore, M & Moatar, F 2017, 'Nonlinear empirical modeling to estimate phosphorus exports using continuous records of turbidity and discharge', Water Resources Research, vol. 53, no. 9, pp. 7590-7606. https://doi.org/10.1002/2017WR020590

Nonlinear empirical modeling to estimate phosphorus exports using continuous records of turbidity and discharge. / Minaudo, C.; Dupas, R.; Gascuel-Odoux, C.; Fovet, O.; Mellander, P.-E.; Jordan, P.; Shore, M.; Moatar, F.

In: Water Resources Research, Vol. 53, No. 9, 01.09.2017, p. 7590-7606.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Nonlinear empirical modeling to estimate phosphorus exports using continuous records of turbidity and discharge

AU - Minaudo, C.

AU - Dupas, R.

AU - Gascuel-Odoux, C.

AU - Fovet, O.

AU - Mellander, P.-E.

AU - Jordan, P.

AU - Shore, M.

AU - Moatar, F.

PY - 2017/9/1

Y1 - 2017/9/1

N2 - We tested an empirical modeling approach using relatively low-cost continuous records of turbidity and discharge as proxies to estimate phosphorus (P) concentrations at a subhourly time step for estimating loads. The method takes into account nonlinearity and hysteresis effects during storm events, and hydrological conditions variability. High-frequency records of total P and reactive P originating from four contrasting European agricultural catchments in terms of P loads were used to test the method. The models were calibrated on weekly grab sampling data combined with 10 storms surveyed subhourly per year (weekly+ survey) and then used to reconstruct P concentrations during all storm events for computing annual loads. For total P, results showed that this modeling approach allowed the estimation of annual loads with limited uncertainties (≈ −10% ± 15%), more reliable than estimations based on simple linear regressions using turbidity, based on interpolated weekly+ data without storm event reconstruction, or on discharge weighted calculations from weekly series or monthly series. For reactive P, load uncertainties based on the nonlinear model were similar to uncertainties based on storm event reconstruction using simple linear regression (≈ 20% ± 30%), and remained lower than uncertainties obtained without storm reconstruction on weekly or monthly series, but larger than uncertainties based on interpolated weekly+ data (≈ −15% ± 20%). These empirical models showed we could estimate reliable P exports from noncontinuous P time series when using continuous proxies, and this could potentially be very useful for completing time-series data sets in high-frequency surveys, even over extended periods.

AB - We tested an empirical modeling approach using relatively low-cost continuous records of turbidity and discharge as proxies to estimate phosphorus (P) concentrations at a subhourly time step for estimating loads. The method takes into account nonlinearity and hysteresis effects during storm events, and hydrological conditions variability. High-frequency records of total P and reactive P originating from four contrasting European agricultural catchments in terms of P loads were used to test the method. The models were calibrated on weekly grab sampling data combined with 10 storms surveyed subhourly per year (weekly+ survey) and then used to reconstruct P concentrations during all storm events for computing annual loads. For total P, results showed that this modeling approach allowed the estimation of annual loads with limited uncertainties (≈ −10% ± 15%), more reliable than estimations based on simple linear regressions using turbidity, based on interpolated weekly+ data without storm event reconstruction, or on discharge weighted calculations from weekly series or monthly series. For reactive P, load uncertainties based on the nonlinear model were similar to uncertainties based on storm event reconstruction using simple linear regression (≈ 20% ± 30%), and remained lower than uncertainties obtained without storm reconstruction on weekly or monthly series, but larger than uncertainties based on interpolated weekly+ data (≈ −15% ± 20%). These empirical models showed we could estimate reliable P exports from noncontinuous P time series when using continuous proxies, and this could potentially be very useful for completing time-series data sets in high-frequency surveys, even over extended periods.

KW - Phosphorus

KW - non-linear empirical modelling

KW - high-frequency monitoring

KW - proxies

KW - hysteresis

U2 - 10.1002/2017WR020590

DO - 10.1002/2017WR020590

M3 - Article

VL - 53

SP - 7590

EP - 7606

JO - Water Resources Research

T2 - Water Resources Research

JF - Water Resources Research

SN - 0043-1397

IS - 9

ER -