Modelling Construction Innovation Contraints: A Tool for Sustaining Innovation in Projects

Martina Murphy, Srinath Perera, George Heaney

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

There is concern that the construction industry lacks the ability to effectively sustain product innovation through the project process. A review of literature identifies lost opportunities where product innovations were introduced into construction projects but poorly managed, thus not fully implemented. Whilst literature points to project constraints for this failure it is proposed that the problem lies rather in the failure of stakeholders to adequately manage the constraints. Previous construction innovation research has failed to substantially evaluate and priortise constraints in implementing innovations into projects thus leading to a gap in knowledge of how Project Managers might manage these constraints to ensure successful adoption of the innovation. This paper presents a methodology for quantifying and modelling innovation constraints using FMEA and Perceptual Mapping techniques.An iterative grounded theory approach was used to identify constraint data from 30 case studies of construction projects where a product innovation was introduced. Constraint data was extracted and quantified from the case studies using content analysis and Failure Mode and Effect Analysis (FMEA). The resultant data was subject to manipulation using perceptual mapping techniques to formulate an Innovation Management Flowchart (IMF) and Constraint Classification Matrix (CCM). These outputs map the critical management tasks with the appropriate stakeholder responses to determine the optimum workflow sequence required to successfully implement an innovation into a construction project. A key attribute of Perceptual Mapping is that it can communicate both qualitative as well as quantitative information thereby enabling the outputs to be used by non-academic beneficiaries. The benefit of this research is an established methodology and communication framework which can be used by Project Managers to inform the risk management strategy for their projects.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationUnknown Host Publication
Place of PublicationKármán Stúdió, Budapest
Pages525-535
Number of pages942
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 9 Jul 2013
EventCreative Construction Conference - Budapest, Hungary
Duration: 9 Jul 2013 → …

Conference

ConferenceCreative Construction Conference
Period9/07/13 → …

Fingerprint

Modeling
Innovation
Perceptual mapping
Product innovation
Construction project
Failure modes and effects analysis
Methodology
Project manager
Stakeholders
Critical management
Content analysis
Risk management
Communication
Flowchart
Management strategy
Innovation management
Manipulation
Construction industry
Grounded theory

Keywords

  • FMEA
  • innovation constraints
  • perceptual mapping
  • procurement
  • product innovation

Cite this

Murphy, M., Perera, S., & Heaney, G. (Accepted/In press). Modelling Construction Innovation Contraints: A Tool for Sustaining Innovation in Projects. In Unknown Host Publication (pp. 525-535). Kármán Stúdió, Budapest.
Murphy, Martina ; Perera, Srinath ; Heaney, George. / Modelling Construction Innovation Contraints: A Tool for Sustaining Innovation in Projects. Unknown Host Publication. Kármán Stúdió, Budapest, 2013. pp. 525-535
@inproceedings{1c064cc281b340869d7bb5ba63646a47,
title = "Modelling Construction Innovation Contraints: A Tool for Sustaining Innovation in Projects",
abstract = "There is concern that the construction industry lacks the ability to effectively sustain product innovation through the project process. A review of literature identifies lost opportunities where product innovations were introduced into construction projects but poorly managed, thus not fully implemented. Whilst literature points to project constraints for this failure it is proposed that the problem lies rather in the failure of stakeholders to adequately manage the constraints. Previous construction innovation research has failed to substantially evaluate and priortise constraints in implementing innovations into projects thus leading to a gap in knowledge of how Project Managers might manage these constraints to ensure successful adoption of the innovation. This paper presents a methodology for quantifying and modelling innovation constraints using FMEA and Perceptual Mapping techniques.An iterative grounded theory approach was used to identify constraint data from 30 case studies of construction projects where a product innovation was introduced. Constraint data was extracted and quantified from the case studies using content analysis and Failure Mode and Effect Analysis (FMEA). The resultant data was subject to manipulation using perceptual mapping techniques to formulate an Innovation Management Flowchart (IMF) and Constraint Classification Matrix (CCM). These outputs map the critical management tasks with the appropriate stakeholder responses to determine the optimum workflow sequence required to successfully implement an innovation into a construction project. A key attribute of Perceptual Mapping is that it can communicate both qualitative as well as quantitative information thereby enabling the outputs to be used by non-academic beneficiaries. The benefit of this research is an established methodology and communication framework which can be used by Project Managers to inform the risk management strategy for their projects.",
keywords = "FMEA, innovation constraints, perceptual mapping, procurement, product innovation",
author = "Martina Murphy and Srinath Perera and George Heaney",
note = "Hard copy in BERI Office.",
year = "2013",
month = "7",
day = "9",
language = "English",
isbn = "978-963-269-366-8",
pages = "525--535",
booktitle = "Unknown Host Publication",

}

Murphy, M, Perera, S & Heaney, G 2013, Modelling Construction Innovation Contraints: A Tool for Sustaining Innovation in Projects. in Unknown Host Publication. Kármán Stúdió, Budapest, pp. 525-535, Creative Construction Conference, 9/07/13.

Modelling Construction Innovation Contraints: A Tool for Sustaining Innovation in Projects. / Murphy, Martina; Perera, Srinath; Heaney, George.

Unknown Host Publication. Kármán Stúdió, Budapest, 2013. p. 525-535.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

TY - GEN

T1 - Modelling Construction Innovation Contraints: A Tool for Sustaining Innovation in Projects

AU - Murphy, Martina

AU - Perera, Srinath

AU - Heaney, George

N1 - Hard copy in BERI Office.

PY - 2013/7/9

Y1 - 2013/7/9

N2 - There is concern that the construction industry lacks the ability to effectively sustain product innovation through the project process. A review of literature identifies lost opportunities where product innovations were introduced into construction projects but poorly managed, thus not fully implemented. Whilst literature points to project constraints for this failure it is proposed that the problem lies rather in the failure of stakeholders to adequately manage the constraints. Previous construction innovation research has failed to substantially evaluate and priortise constraints in implementing innovations into projects thus leading to a gap in knowledge of how Project Managers might manage these constraints to ensure successful adoption of the innovation. This paper presents a methodology for quantifying and modelling innovation constraints using FMEA and Perceptual Mapping techniques.An iterative grounded theory approach was used to identify constraint data from 30 case studies of construction projects where a product innovation was introduced. Constraint data was extracted and quantified from the case studies using content analysis and Failure Mode and Effect Analysis (FMEA). The resultant data was subject to manipulation using perceptual mapping techniques to formulate an Innovation Management Flowchart (IMF) and Constraint Classification Matrix (CCM). These outputs map the critical management tasks with the appropriate stakeholder responses to determine the optimum workflow sequence required to successfully implement an innovation into a construction project. A key attribute of Perceptual Mapping is that it can communicate both qualitative as well as quantitative information thereby enabling the outputs to be used by non-academic beneficiaries. The benefit of this research is an established methodology and communication framework which can be used by Project Managers to inform the risk management strategy for their projects.

AB - There is concern that the construction industry lacks the ability to effectively sustain product innovation through the project process. A review of literature identifies lost opportunities where product innovations were introduced into construction projects but poorly managed, thus not fully implemented. Whilst literature points to project constraints for this failure it is proposed that the problem lies rather in the failure of stakeholders to adequately manage the constraints. Previous construction innovation research has failed to substantially evaluate and priortise constraints in implementing innovations into projects thus leading to a gap in knowledge of how Project Managers might manage these constraints to ensure successful adoption of the innovation. This paper presents a methodology for quantifying and modelling innovation constraints using FMEA and Perceptual Mapping techniques.An iterative grounded theory approach was used to identify constraint data from 30 case studies of construction projects where a product innovation was introduced. Constraint data was extracted and quantified from the case studies using content analysis and Failure Mode and Effect Analysis (FMEA). The resultant data was subject to manipulation using perceptual mapping techniques to formulate an Innovation Management Flowchart (IMF) and Constraint Classification Matrix (CCM). These outputs map the critical management tasks with the appropriate stakeholder responses to determine the optimum workflow sequence required to successfully implement an innovation into a construction project. A key attribute of Perceptual Mapping is that it can communicate both qualitative as well as quantitative information thereby enabling the outputs to be used by non-academic beneficiaries. The benefit of this research is an established methodology and communication framework which can be used by Project Managers to inform the risk management strategy for their projects.

KW - FMEA

KW - innovation constraints

KW - perceptual mapping

KW - procurement

KW - product innovation

M3 - Conference contribution

SN - 978-963-269-366-8

SP - 525

EP - 535

BT - Unknown Host Publication

CY - Kármán Stúdió, Budapest

ER -

Murphy M, Perera S, Heaney G. Modelling Construction Innovation Contraints: A Tool for Sustaining Innovation in Projects. In Unknown Host Publication. Kármán Stúdió, Budapest. 2013. p. 525-535