‘Liberalism, Citizenship and the Welfare State’

Julia S O'Connor, Gillian Robinson

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

15 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This chapter is based on the argument that aspects of liberalism have influenced the development of the welfare state irrespective of regime categorization. The negative influence of neo-liberalism in restructuring welfare states since the 1980s has been widely identified and is discussed in this paper where it is situated within the context of a discussion of the key tenets of liberalism that still have, a sometimes positive, sometimes negative and often contradictory influence on western welfare states. The economic dimension of liberalism, with its emphasis on the primacy of the market, is one dimension of the configuration of ideas embodied in liberalism that have relevance to welfare state analysis. This configuration includes individualism, moral egalitarianism and universalism although the particular liberal denotation of these concepts has to be borne in mind and their implications for social policy examined in the context of the dual character of contemporary liberal democracies. The twin pillars of these societies are a capitalist economic system and a democratic political system. The central issue that must inform analysis of welfare states in such systems is the balance between these pillars and the extent to which inequalities associated with the market are modified through the democratic system. The implications of this analysis of liberalism, in its various dimensions, are that a cultural dimension is an essential component of an explanatory framework for cross-national welfare state research and that the contemporary influence of liberalism is not confined to neo-liberalism; a positive liberal influence on policy development, if considerably modified by other streams of thought, may be more pervasive than is often assumed.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationCulture and the Welfare State
EditorsWim van Oorschot, Michael Opielka, Birgit Pfau-Effinger
Pages29-49
Publication statusPublished - 2008

Fingerprint

liberalism
welfare state
citizenship
neoliberalism
egalitarianism
universalism
market
economic system
individualism
political system
development policy
restructuring
regime
democracy
society
economics

Cite this

O'Connor, J. S., & Robinson, G. (2008). ‘Liberalism, Citizenship and the Welfare State’. In W. van Oorschot, M. Opielka, & B. Pfau-Effinger (Eds.), Culture and the Welfare State (pp. 29-49)
O'Connor, Julia S ; Robinson, Gillian. / ‘Liberalism, Citizenship and the Welfare State’. Culture and the Welfare State. editor / Wim van Oorschot ; Michael Opielka ; Birgit Pfau-Effinger. 2008. pp. 29-49
@inbook{b8accedd166a4b229bf879a0a2ecbdbe,
title = "‘Liberalism, Citizenship and the Welfare State’",
abstract = "This chapter is based on the argument that aspects of liberalism have influenced the development of the welfare state irrespective of regime categorization. The negative influence of neo-liberalism in restructuring welfare states since the 1980s has been widely identified and is discussed in this paper where it is situated within the context of a discussion of the key tenets of liberalism that still have, a sometimes positive, sometimes negative and often contradictory influence on western welfare states. The economic dimension of liberalism, with its emphasis on the primacy of the market, is one dimension of the configuration of ideas embodied in liberalism that have relevance to welfare state analysis. This configuration includes individualism, moral egalitarianism and universalism although the particular liberal denotation of these concepts has to be borne in mind and their implications for social policy examined in the context of the dual character of contemporary liberal democracies. The twin pillars of these societies are a capitalist economic system and a democratic political system. The central issue that must inform analysis of welfare states in such systems is the balance between these pillars and the extent to which inequalities associated with the market are modified through the democratic system. The implications of this analysis of liberalism, in its various dimensions, are that a cultural dimension is an essential component of an explanatory framework for cross-national welfare state research and that the contemporary influence of liberalism is not confined to neo-liberalism; a positive liberal influence on policy development, if considerably modified by other streams of thought, may be more pervasive than is often assumed.",
author = "O'Connor, {Julia S} and Gillian Robinson",
year = "2008",
language = "English",
isbn = "978 1 84542 389 6",
pages = "29--49",
editor = "{van Oorschot}, Wim and Michael Opielka and Birgit Pfau-Effinger",
booktitle = "Culture and the Welfare State",

}

O'Connor, JS & Robinson, G 2008, ‘Liberalism, Citizenship and the Welfare State’. in W van Oorschot, M Opielka & B Pfau-Effinger (eds), Culture and the Welfare State. pp. 29-49.

‘Liberalism, Citizenship and the Welfare State’. / O'Connor, Julia S; Robinson, Gillian.

Culture and the Welfare State. ed. / Wim van Oorschot; Michael Opielka; Birgit Pfau-Effinger. 2008. p. 29-49.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - ‘Liberalism, Citizenship and the Welfare State’

AU - O'Connor, Julia S

AU - Robinson, Gillian

PY - 2008

Y1 - 2008

N2 - This chapter is based on the argument that aspects of liberalism have influenced the development of the welfare state irrespective of regime categorization. The negative influence of neo-liberalism in restructuring welfare states since the 1980s has been widely identified and is discussed in this paper where it is situated within the context of a discussion of the key tenets of liberalism that still have, a sometimes positive, sometimes negative and often contradictory influence on western welfare states. The economic dimension of liberalism, with its emphasis on the primacy of the market, is one dimension of the configuration of ideas embodied in liberalism that have relevance to welfare state analysis. This configuration includes individualism, moral egalitarianism and universalism although the particular liberal denotation of these concepts has to be borne in mind and their implications for social policy examined in the context of the dual character of contemporary liberal democracies. The twin pillars of these societies are a capitalist economic system and a democratic political system. The central issue that must inform analysis of welfare states in such systems is the balance between these pillars and the extent to which inequalities associated with the market are modified through the democratic system. The implications of this analysis of liberalism, in its various dimensions, are that a cultural dimension is an essential component of an explanatory framework for cross-national welfare state research and that the contemporary influence of liberalism is not confined to neo-liberalism; a positive liberal influence on policy development, if considerably modified by other streams of thought, may be more pervasive than is often assumed.

AB - This chapter is based on the argument that aspects of liberalism have influenced the development of the welfare state irrespective of regime categorization. The negative influence of neo-liberalism in restructuring welfare states since the 1980s has been widely identified and is discussed in this paper where it is situated within the context of a discussion of the key tenets of liberalism that still have, a sometimes positive, sometimes negative and often contradictory influence on western welfare states. The economic dimension of liberalism, with its emphasis on the primacy of the market, is one dimension of the configuration of ideas embodied in liberalism that have relevance to welfare state analysis. This configuration includes individualism, moral egalitarianism and universalism although the particular liberal denotation of these concepts has to be borne in mind and their implications for social policy examined in the context of the dual character of contemporary liberal democracies. The twin pillars of these societies are a capitalist economic system and a democratic political system. The central issue that must inform analysis of welfare states in such systems is the balance between these pillars and the extent to which inequalities associated with the market are modified through the democratic system. The implications of this analysis of liberalism, in its various dimensions, are that a cultural dimension is an essential component of an explanatory framework for cross-national welfare state research and that the contemporary influence of liberalism is not confined to neo-liberalism; a positive liberal influence on policy development, if considerably modified by other streams of thought, may be more pervasive than is often assumed.

M3 - Chapter

SN - 978 1 84542 389 6

SP - 29

EP - 49

BT - Culture and the Welfare State

A2 - van Oorschot, Wim

A2 - Opielka, Michael

A2 - Pfau-Effinger, Birgit

ER -

O'Connor JS, Robinson G. ‘Liberalism, Citizenship and the Welfare State’. In van Oorschot W, Opielka M, Pfau-Effinger B, editors, Culture and the Welfare State. 2008. p. 29-49