Is Microcredit a Debt Trap for the Poor? Sifting Reality from Myth

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

12 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

There appears to exist a deep-seated scepticism about microcredit in popular perception in Bangladesh. One manifestation of this scepticism is the oft-repeated allegation that microcredit is leading hordes of borrowers into a ‘debt trap’. The empirical basis of this allegation has never been established, though, beyond some anecdotal evidence. The present paper makes the first systematic attempt to empirically investigate the existence, nature and magnitude of debt trap among microcredit borrowers in Bangladesh. The investigation relies on a large-scale nationally representative rural household survey, covering the period 2007-2013. The paper begins by examining the prevalence of two inter-related practices – namely, ‘overlapping borrowing’ and ‘borrowing to repay’, which are often taken as indicators of debt trap in popular discussion of the subject. The paper argues that that although these practices could sometimes lead to a debt trap, neither of them necessarily does so, so that the magnitude of debt traps could not be deduced from the magnitude of these practices. After defining the criteria for identifying a debt trap, the paper finds that debt traps can be said to characterise at most 4.5 per cent of microcredit borrowers who engage in ‘borrowing to repay’ and only about 1.4 per cent of all microcredit borrowers. Furthermore, even in these few cases, microcredit cannot generally be held responsible for their plight. Debt traps occur when extremely vulnerable households are faced with overwhelming shocks; and the role of microcredit here is one of mitigation rather than causation. That is, in most cases, debt trap occurs not because of but in spite of microcredit; as such, its occurrence reflects not so much the failure of microcredit as the failure of the society at large to look after its most vulnerable people.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1-41
Number of pages42
JournalThe Bangladesh Development Studies
VolumeXXXX
Issue numberB
Publication statusPublished - 1 Dec 2017

Keywords

  • Microcredit
  • Debt Trap
  • Overlapping borrowing
  • Borrowing to repay

Fingerprint Dive into the research topics of 'Is Microcredit a Debt Trap for the Poor? Sifting Reality from Myth'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

  • Profiles

    No photo of Siddiqur Osmani

    Siddiqur Osmani

    Person: Academic

    Cite this