International Law and Domestic Gender Justice, or Why Case Studies Matter

Research output: Research - peer-reviewChapter

Abstract

This chapter reflects on the relationship of feminist-informed developments in international criminal law (ICL) to the gender outcomes of domestic processes of transitional justice. The paper identifies a distinct critical-reflective turn in feminist scholarship in international criminal law, and offers a four-way typology of these more recent feminist critiques of ICL, namely: ICL as legally deficient; ICL as sexualizing and infantilizing women; ICL as silencing individual women and women’s movements more broadly; and feminist engagement with ICL as hegemonic and imperialist. The chapter notes the move in feminist ICL scholarship away from a concern with the impact of ICL norms on domestic cases of transition. The chapter then draws on the Chilean case in order to consider the impact of evolving international legal norms on the official recognition of harms experienced by women under the dictatorship. The chapter argues that attention to the impact of international legal norms on domestic instances of transition might go some way to re-grounding feminist critical-reflective scholarship of ICL, moving away from more abstract critiques at the international level, to applied critiques at the domestic level of gender and transitional justice. Moreover, attending to the domestic impact of international legal norms might provide grounds for greater optimism in the evaluation of the feminist-informed changes in ICL over the past decade and a half.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationFeminist Perspectives on Transitional Justice: From International and Criminal to Alternative Forms of Justice
Pages11-41
StatePublished - 30 Mar 2013

Fingerprint

criminal law
international law
justice
gender
legal norm
women's movement
dictatorship
optimism
typology

Keywords

  • Transitional Justice
  • International Criminal Law
  • Gender
  • Chile
  • Sexual Violence
  • Governance Feminism

Cite this

O'Rourke, C. (2013). International Law and Domestic Gender Justice, or Why Case Studies Matter. In Feminist Perspectives on Transitional Justice: From International and Criminal to Alternative Forms of Justice (pp. 11-41)
O'Rourke, Catherine. / International Law and Domestic Gender Justice, or Why Case Studies Matter. Feminist Perspectives on Transitional Justice: From International and Criminal to Alternative Forms of Justice. 2013. pp. 11-41
@inbook{41a41a2964c541e8abcea9165fc26821,
title = "International Law and Domestic Gender Justice, or Why Case Studies Matter",
abstract = "This chapter reflects on the relationship of feminist-informed developments in international criminal law (ICL) to the gender outcomes of domestic processes of transitional justice. The paper identifies a distinct critical-reflective turn in feminist scholarship in international criminal law, and offers a four-way typology of these more recent feminist critiques of ICL, namely: ICL as legally deficient; ICL as sexualizing and infantilizing women; ICL as silencing individual women and women’s movements more broadly; and feminist engagement with ICL as hegemonic and imperialist. The chapter notes the move in feminist ICL scholarship away from a concern with the impact of ICL norms on domestic cases of transition. The chapter then draws on the Chilean case in order to consider the impact of evolving international legal norms on the official recognition of harms experienced by women under the dictatorship. The chapter argues that attention to the impact of international legal norms on domestic instances of transition might go some way to re-grounding feminist critical-reflective scholarship of ICL, moving away from more abstract critiques at the international level, to applied critiques at the domestic level of gender and transitional justice. Moreover, attending to the domestic impact of international legal norms might provide grounds for greater optimism in the evaluation of the feminist-informed changes in ICL over the past decade and a half.",
keywords = "Transitional Justice, International Criminal Law, Gender, Chile, Sexual Violence, Governance Feminism",
author = "Catherine O'Rourke",
year = "2013",
month = "3",
isbn = "978-1-78068-142-9",
pages = "11--41",
booktitle = "Feminist Perspectives on Transitional Justice: From International and Criminal to Alternative Forms of Justice",

}

O'Rourke, C 2013, International Law and Domestic Gender Justice, or Why Case Studies Matter. in Feminist Perspectives on Transitional Justice: From International and Criminal to Alternative Forms of Justice. pp. 11-41.

International Law and Domestic Gender Justice, or Why Case Studies Matter. / O'Rourke, Catherine.

Feminist Perspectives on Transitional Justice: From International and Criminal to Alternative Forms of Justice. 2013. p. 11-41.

Research output: Research - peer-reviewChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - International Law and Domestic Gender Justice, or Why Case Studies Matter

AU - O'Rourke,Catherine

PY - 2013/3/30

Y1 - 2013/3/30

N2 - This chapter reflects on the relationship of feminist-informed developments in international criminal law (ICL) to the gender outcomes of domestic processes of transitional justice. The paper identifies a distinct critical-reflective turn in feminist scholarship in international criminal law, and offers a four-way typology of these more recent feminist critiques of ICL, namely: ICL as legally deficient; ICL as sexualizing and infantilizing women; ICL as silencing individual women and women’s movements more broadly; and feminist engagement with ICL as hegemonic and imperialist. The chapter notes the move in feminist ICL scholarship away from a concern with the impact of ICL norms on domestic cases of transition. The chapter then draws on the Chilean case in order to consider the impact of evolving international legal norms on the official recognition of harms experienced by women under the dictatorship. The chapter argues that attention to the impact of international legal norms on domestic instances of transition might go some way to re-grounding feminist critical-reflective scholarship of ICL, moving away from more abstract critiques at the international level, to applied critiques at the domestic level of gender and transitional justice. Moreover, attending to the domestic impact of international legal norms might provide grounds for greater optimism in the evaluation of the feminist-informed changes in ICL over the past decade and a half.

AB - This chapter reflects on the relationship of feminist-informed developments in international criminal law (ICL) to the gender outcomes of domestic processes of transitional justice. The paper identifies a distinct critical-reflective turn in feminist scholarship in international criminal law, and offers a four-way typology of these more recent feminist critiques of ICL, namely: ICL as legally deficient; ICL as sexualizing and infantilizing women; ICL as silencing individual women and women’s movements more broadly; and feminist engagement with ICL as hegemonic and imperialist. The chapter notes the move in feminist ICL scholarship away from a concern with the impact of ICL norms on domestic cases of transition. The chapter then draws on the Chilean case in order to consider the impact of evolving international legal norms on the official recognition of harms experienced by women under the dictatorship. The chapter argues that attention to the impact of international legal norms on domestic instances of transition might go some way to re-grounding feminist critical-reflective scholarship of ICL, moving away from more abstract critiques at the international level, to applied critiques at the domestic level of gender and transitional justice. Moreover, attending to the domestic impact of international legal norms might provide grounds for greater optimism in the evaluation of the feminist-informed changes in ICL over the past decade and a half.

KW - Transitional Justice

KW - International Criminal Law

KW - Gender

KW - Chile

KW - Sexual Violence

KW - Governance Feminism

M3 - Chapter

SN - 978-1-78068-142-9

SP - 11

EP - 41

BT - Feminist Perspectives on Transitional Justice: From International and Criminal to Alternative Forms of Justice

ER -

O'Rourke C. International Law and Domestic Gender Justice, or Why Case Studies Matter. In Feminist Perspectives on Transitional Justice: From International and Criminal to Alternative Forms of Justice. 2013. p. 11-41.