GENDER DIFFERENCES IN SELF-ESTIMATED IQ - THE NEED FOR CARE IN INTERPRETING GROUP DATA

J REILLY, G MULHERN

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This study sought to examine differences between estimated intelligence and measured IQ among males and females. Forty-six male and 80 female participants were asked to estimate their own IQ and to complete the Digit Symbol and Vocabulary tests from the WAIS. Analysis of group data revealed a significant gender difference in self-estimated IQ, with male self-estimates higher on average than those of females. Moreover, male self-estimates were found to be significantly higher overall than their measured IQs and female self-estimates were lower than measured IQ, although not significantly. Consideration of these results at individual level, however, indicated that, for the majority of subjects, the overall pattern of results for males and females was strikingly similar and that statistically significant group differences were due to a few `outliers' who displayed large discrepancies between estimated and measured IQ. It was concluded that speculation about the causality of inaccurate self-estimates of IQ should not be based on the assumption that gender differences at group level represent a generalized tendency on the part of either sex to either over-confidence or lack of confidence with regard to their own intelligence.
LanguageEnglish
Pages189-192
JournalPersonality and Individual Differences
Volume18
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - Feb 1995

Fingerprint

need for care
gender-specific factors
intelligence
confidence
Group
speculation
causality
vocabulary
symbol
lack

Cite this

@article{0d068119eeb84033aeb5fb9c375c2741,
title = "GENDER DIFFERENCES IN SELF-ESTIMATED IQ - THE NEED FOR CARE IN INTERPRETING GROUP DATA",
abstract = "This study sought to examine differences between estimated intelligence and measured IQ among males and females. Forty-six male and 80 female participants were asked to estimate their own IQ and to complete the Digit Symbol and Vocabulary tests from the WAIS. Analysis of group data revealed a significant gender difference in self-estimated IQ, with male self-estimates higher on average than those of females. Moreover, male self-estimates were found to be significantly higher overall than their measured IQs and female self-estimates were lower than measured IQ, although not significantly. Consideration of these results at individual level, however, indicated that, for the majority of subjects, the overall pattern of results for males and females was strikingly similar and that statistically significant group differences were due to a few `outliers' who displayed large discrepancies between estimated and measured IQ. It was concluded that speculation about the causality of inaccurate self-estimates of IQ should not be based on the assumption that gender differences at group level represent a generalized tendency on the part of either sex to either over-confidence or lack of confidence with regard to their own intelligence.",
author = "J REILLY and G MULHERN",
year = "1995",
month = "2",
language = "English",
volume = "18",
pages = "189--192",
journal = "Personality and Individual Differences",
issn = "0191-8869",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "2",

}

GENDER DIFFERENCES IN SELF-ESTIMATED IQ - THE NEED FOR CARE IN INTERPRETING GROUP DATA. / REILLY, J; MULHERN, G.

In: Personality and Individual Differences, Vol. 18, No. 2, 02.1995, p. 189-192.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - GENDER DIFFERENCES IN SELF-ESTIMATED IQ - THE NEED FOR CARE IN INTERPRETING GROUP DATA

AU - REILLY, J

AU - MULHERN, G

PY - 1995/2

Y1 - 1995/2

N2 - This study sought to examine differences between estimated intelligence and measured IQ among males and females. Forty-six male and 80 female participants were asked to estimate their own IQ and to complete the Digit Symbol and Vocabulary tests from the WAIS. Analysis of group data revealed a significant gender difference in self-estimated IQ, with male self-estimates higher on average than those of females. Moreover, male self-estimates were found to be significantly higher overall than their measured IQs and female self-estimates were lower than measured IQ, although not significantly. Consideration of these results at individual level, however, indicated that, for the majority of subjects, the overall pattern of results for males and females was strikingly similar and that statistically significant group differences were due to a few `outliers' who displayed large discrepancies between estimated and measured IQ. It was concluded that speculation about the causality of inaccurate self-estimates of IQ should not be based on the assumption that gender differences at group level represent a generalized tendency on the part of either sex to either over-confidence or lack of confidence with regard to their own intelligence.

AB - This study sought to examine differences between estimated intelligence and measured IQ among males and females. Forty-six male and 80 female participants were asked to estimate their own IQ and to complete the Digit Symbol and Vocabulary tests from the WAIS. Analysis of group data revealed a significant gender difference in self-estimated IQ, with male self-estimates higher on average than those of females. Moreover, male self-estimates were found to be significantly higher overall than their measured IQs and female self-estimates were lower than measured IQ, although not significantly. Consideration of these results at individual level, however, indicated that, for the majority of subjects, the overall pattern of results for males and females was strikingly similar and that statistically significant group differences were due to a few `outliers' who displayed large discrepancies between estimated and measured IQ. It was concluded that speculation about the causality of inaccurate self-estimates of IQ should not be based on the assumption that gender differences at group level represent a generalized tendency on the part of either sex to either over-confidence or lack of confidence with regard to their own intelligence.

M3 - Article

VL - 18

SP - 189

EP - 192

JO - Personality and Individual Differences

T2 - Personality and Individual Differences

JF - Personality and Individual Differences

SN - 0191-8869

IS - 2

ER -