From Ridicule to Legitimacy? 'Contested languages' and Devolved Language Planning

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

In 1999, devolved governance was established in Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland which altered the contours of language recognition in the United Kingdom. Whilst much focus has been placed on how devolution improved the status of Welsh, Scottish Gaelic and Irish, less attention has been placed on those minority vernaculars with ‘contested’ linguistic status. Scots in Scotland and Ulster-Scots in Northern Ireland fall into such a category as they are considered by some as merely ‘dialects’ of English but by others as independent regional languages. The formation of the Edinburgh and Belfast legislatures created policy processes closer to the point of application and has ensured that policy decisions, including those relating to language, have been influenced by the nuances of local identity (Birrell, 2009). This article, therefore, explores the extent to which devolution in Scotland and Northern Ireland has enhanced the status of Scots and Ulster-Scots in areas such as broadcasting, education and the arts. Whilst supporters in both regions continue to champion better policy coverage, changes since 1999 illustrate how the devolved administrations have facilitated incremental change and evolving policy.
LanguageEnglish
Pages121-139
Number of pages19
JournalCurrent Issues in Language Planning
VolumeOnline
Early online date8 May 2018
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 8 May 2018

Fingerprint

legitimacy
planning
language
decentralization
broadcasting
dialect
coverage
minority
art
governance
linguistics
education

Keywords

  • Scots
  • Ulster-Scots
  • Language Policy
  • Devolution
  • Northern Ireland
  • Scotland

Cite this

@article{4d2a38835c0c4c73989e3708c17ea563,
title = "From Ridicule to Legitimacy? 'Contested languages' and Devolved Language Planning",
abstract = "In 1999, devolved governance was established in Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland which altered the contours of language recognition in the United Kingdom. Whilst much focus has been placed on how devolution improved the status of Welsh, Scottish Gaelic and Irish, less attention has been placed on those minority vernaculars with ‘contested’ linguistic status. Scots in Scotland and Ulster-Scots in Northern Ireland fall into such a category as they are considered by some as merely ‘dialects’ of English but by others as independent regional languages. The formation of the Edinburgh and Belfast legislatures created policy processes closer to the point of application and has ensured that policy decisions, including those relating to language, have been influenced by the nuances of local identity (Birrell, 2009). This article, therefore, explores the extent to which devolution in Scotland and Northern Ireland has enhanced the status of Scots and Ulster-Scots in areas such as broadcasting, education and the arts. Whilst supporters in both regions continue to champion better policy coverage, changes since 1999 illustrate how the devolved administrations have facilitated incremental change and evolving policy.",
keywords = "Scots, Ulster-Scots, Language Policy, Devolution, Northern Ireland, Scotland",
author = "Philip McDermott",
note = "UIR Compliance not yet assessed as still under embargo - evidence uploaded to other files",
year = "2018",
month = "5",
day = "8",
doi = "10.1080/14664208.2018.1468961",
language = "English",
volume = "Online",
pages = "121--139",
journal = "Current Issues in Language Planning",
issn = "1466-4208",

}

From Ridicule to Legitimacy? 'Contested languages' and Devolved Language Planning. / McDermott, Philip.

In: Current Issues in Language Planning, Vol. Online, 08.05.2018, p. 121-139.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - From Ridicule to Legitimacy? 'Contested languages' and Devolved Language Planning

AU - McDermott, Philip

N1 - UIR Compliance not yet assessed as still under embargo - evidence uploaded to other files

PY - 2018/5/8

Y1 - 2018/5/8

N2 - In 1999, devolved governance was established in Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland which altered the contours of language recognition in the United Kingdom. Whilst much focus has been placed on how devolution improved the status of Welsh, Scottish Gaelic and Irish, less attention has been placed on those minority vernaculars with ‘contested’ linguistic status. Scots in Scotland and Ulster-Scots in Northern Ireland fall into such a category as they are considered by some as merely ‘dialects’ of English but by others as independent regional languages. The formation of the Edinburgh and Belfast legislatures created policy processes closer to the point of application and has ensured that policy decisions, including those relating to language, have been influenced by the nuances of local identity (Birrell, 2009). This article, therefore, explores the extent to which devolution in Scotland and Northern Ireland has enhanced the status of Scots and Ulster-Scots in areas such as broadcasting, education and the arts. Whilst supporters in both regions continue to champion better policy coverage, changes since 1999 illustrate how the devolved administrations have facilitated incremental change and evolving policy.

AB - In 1999, devolved governance was established in Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland which altered the contours of language recognition in the United Kingdom. Whilst much focus has been placed on how devolution improved the status of Welsh, Scottish Gaelic and Irish, less attention has been placed on those minority vernaculars with ‘contested’ linguistic status. Scots in Scotland and Ulster-Scots in Northern Ireland fall into such a category as they are considered by some as merely ‘dialects’ of English but by others as independent regional languages. The formation of the Edinburgh and Belfast legislatures created policy processes closer to the point of application and has ensured that policy decisions, including those relating to language, have been influenced by the nuances of local identity (Birrell, 2009). This article, therefore, explores the extent to which devolution in Scotland and Northern Ireland has enhanced the status of Scots and Ulster-Scots in areas such as broadcasting, education and the arts. Whilst supporters in both regions continue to champion better policy coverage, changes since 1999 illustrate how the devolved administrations have facilitated incremental change and evolving policy.

KW - Scots

KW - Ulster-Scots

KW - Language Policy

KW - Devolution

KW - Northern Ireland

KW - Scotland

U2 - 10.1080/14664208.2018.1468961

DO - 10.1080/14664208.2018.1468961

M3 - Article

VL - Online

SP - 121

EP - 139

JO - Current Issues in Language Planning

T2 - Current Issues in Language Planning

JF - Current Issues in Language Planning

SN - 1466-4208

ER -