Factorial surveys: using vignettes to study professional judgement

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

157 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Decision making is becoming an increasingly central feature of social work practice, yet there is limited research on the topic. Experimental methods of investigating decision making tend to be constrained by practical and ethical difficulties, whilst questions about validity and generalisability surround ethnographic and other descriptive methods.
It is argued here that the factorial survey addresses these methodological difficulties as a research design to study the way that professionals make decisions in real life. In this research design, true-to-life vignettes (case scenarios or paper cases) are presented to social workers or other staff to make a judgement about a familiar type of scenario. The randomised factors within the vignettes, combined with the randomisation of the selection of vignettes for each decision maker, gives the factorial survey a unique capability to investigate the effect of multiple factors in complex decisions, unlike the more common factorial experiment.
The method is explained, and prospects and issues for the development of this research design to study professional judgement within social work are discussed. The factorial survey has potential as a method for rigorous study of the impact of client, family and context factors on decisions by social work and social care staff.
LanguageEnglish
Pages1187-1207
Number of pages21
JournalBritish Journal of Social Work
Volume36
Issue number7
Publication statusPublished - 31 Oct 2006

Fingerprint

Social Work
research planning
social work
Research Design
Decision Making
scenario
staff
decision making
Random Allocation
social worker
decision maker
Surveys and Questionnaires
experiment
Research

Keywords

  • decision making; professional judgement; research methods; factorial survey; vignettes; assessment; risk.

Cite this

@article{0d2b605471be431ea4d255ac1f5faa6b,
title = "Factorial surveys: using vignettes to study professional judgement",
abstract = "Decision making is becoming an increasingly central feature of social work practice, yet there is limited research on the topic. Experimental methods of investigating decision making tend to be constrained by practical and ethical difficulties, whilst questions about validity and generalisability surround ethnographic and other descriptive methods. It is argued here that the factorial survey addresses these methodological difficulties as a research design to study the way that professionals make decisions in real life. In this research design, true-to-life vignettes (case scenarios or paper cases) are presented to social workers or other staff to make a judgement about a familiar type of scenario. The randomised factors within the vignettes, combined with the randomisation of the selection of vignettes for each decision maker, gives the factorial survey a unique capability to investigate the effect of multiple factors in complex decisions, unlike the more common factorial experiment.The method is explained, and prospects and issues for the development of this research design to study professional judgement within social work are discussed. The factorial survey has potential as a method for rigorous study of the impact of client, family and context factors on decisions by social work and social care staff.",
keywords = "decision making; professional judgement; research methods; factorial survey; vignettes; assessment; risk.",
author = "Brian Taylor",
year = "2006",
month = "10",
day = "31",
language = "English",
volume = "36",
pages = "1187--1207",
journal = "British Journal of Social Work",
issn = "0045-3102",
number = "7",

}

Factorial surveys: using vignettes to study professional judgement. / Taylor, Brian.

In: British Journal of Social Work, Vol. 36, No. 7, 31.10.2006, p. 1187-1207.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Factorial surveys: using vignettes to study professional judgement

AU - Taylor, Brian

PY - 2006/10/31

Y1 - 2006/10/31

N2 - Decision making is becoming an increasingly central feature of social work practice, yet there is limited research on the topic. Experimental methods of investigating decision making tend to be constrained by practical and ethical difficulties, whilst questions about validity and generalisability surround ethnographic and other descriptive methods. It is argued here that the factorial survey addresses these methodological difficulties as a research design to study the way that professionals make decisions in real life. In this research design, true-to-life vignettes (case scenarios or paper cases) are presented to social workers or other staff to make a judgement about a familiar type of scenario. The randomised factors within the vignettes, combined with the randomisation of the selection of vignettes for each decision maker, gives the factorial survey a unique capability to investigate the effect of multiple factors in complex decisions, unlike the more common factorial experiment.The method is explained, and prospects and issues for the development of this research design to study professional judgement within social work are discussed. The factorial survey has potential as a method for rigorous study of the impact of client, family and context factors on decisions by social work and social care staff.

AB - Decision making is becoming an increasingly central feature of social work practice, yet there is limited research on the topic. Experimental methods of investigating decision making tend to be constrained by practical and ethical difficulties, whilst questions about validity and generalisability surround ethnographic and other descriptive methods. It is argued here that the factorial survey addresses these methodological difficulties as a research design to study the way that professionals make decisions in real life. In this research design, true-to-life vignettes (case scenarios or paper cases) are presented to social workers or other staff to make a judgement about a familiar type of scenario. The randomised factors within the vignettes, combined with the randomisation of the selection of vignettes for each decision maker, gives the factorial survey a unique capability to investigate the effect of multiple factors in complex decisions, unlike the more common factorial experiment.The method is explained, and prospects and issues for the development of this research design to study professional judgement within social work are discussed. The factorial survey has potential as a method for rigorous study of the impact of client, family and context factors on decisions by social work and social care staff.

KW - decision making; professional judgement; research methods; factorial survey; vignettes; assessment; risk.

M3 - Article

VL - 36

SP - 1187

EP - 1207

JO - British Journal of Social Work

T2 - British Journal of Social Work

JF - British Journal of Social Work

SN - 0045-3102

IS - 7

ER -