Critical Reflections on the Coherent Flow Structures Paradigm in Aeolian Geomorphology

B.O. Bauer, I.J. Walker, A.C.W. Baas, Derek Jackson, C. McKenna-Neuman, G.F.S. Wiggs, P.A. Hesp

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

24 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Equilibrium concepts are widespread in aeolian geomorphology. The main objective of this chapter is to reflect critically on whether a new paradigm based on coherent flow structures (CFS) is beginning to emerge as an alternative to our current understanding of aeolian processes, which is predicated on time-averaged flow and transport assessments. A survey of recent research addressing the existence and nature of CFS in aeolian systems indicates that: (1) there is as yet no convincing evidence in support of the classic bursting process or of any discrete flow structure with a characteristic topology (e.g., hairpin vortex) for the case of near-surface boundary layer flow over flat sandy surfaces (with or without saltation); (2) there are instances when near-surface vortices of varying geometry are found in association with small obstacles (e.g., logs, pebbles, vegetation clumps) on sandy surfaces, but it is not always apparent what the pattern of erosion or deposition in the vicinity of the obstacle will be given that there are additional controls that involve surface hardness and sediment delivery from upwind; (3) flow over aeolian dunes is generally well understood and very similar to flow over fluvial dunes with characteristic zonation, including flow acceleration and streamline compression on the stoss slope and a recirculation eddy and wake region in the lee; and (4) the importance of these dune-related flow zones to sediment transport response is more reliably understood through examination of a range of turbulence parameters (e.g., Reynolds stress, turbulent kinetic energy) rather than mean flow quantities alone. In order to advance our understanding of CFS in aeolian geomorphology, it will be essential to develop better technologies for high-frequency monitoring of wind and sediment flux, to focus attention on sediment transport events with specific topologies (e.g., streamers) rather than attempt to capture flow events and hope that there is an accompanying transport signal, to move beyond simple quadrant analysis and adopt analytical methods that elucidate the time-history of event signatures, and to reformulate existing time-averaged parameterizations of sediment flux to incorporate event-based information in ways that are not immediately apparent.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationCoherent Flow Structures at the Earth’s Surface
EditorsJ.G. Venditti, J. Best, H. Church, R.J. Hardy
PagesAccepted-.
Publication statusPublished - 1 Mar 2013

Fingerprint

flow structure
geomorphology
dune
topology
vortex
sediment transport
sediment
saltation
eolian process
pebble
zonation
kinetic energy
hardness
analytical method
surface layer
parameterization
eddy
boundary layer
turbulence
compression

Cite this

Bauer, B. O., Walker, I. J., Baas, A. C. W., Jackson, D., McKenna-Neuman, C., Wiggs, G. F. S., & Hesp, P. A. (2013). Critical Reflections on the Coherent Flow Structures Paradigm in Aeolian Geomorphology. In J. G. Venditti, J. Best, H. Church, & R. J. Hardy (Eds.), Coherent Flow Structures at the Earth’s Surface (pp. Accepted-.)
Bauer, B.O. ; Walker, I.J. ; Baas, A.C.W. ; Jackson, Derek ; McKenna-Neuman, C. ; Wiggs, G.F.S. ; Hesp, P.A. / Critical Reflections on the Coherent Flow Structures Paradigm in Aeolian Geomorphology. Coherent Flow Structures at the Earth’s Surface. editor / J.G. Venditti ; J. Best ; H. Church ; R.J. Hardy. 2013. pp. Accepted-.
@inbook{7ee3a7b0de444578a2bcb7704e644426,
title = "Critical Reflections on the Coherent Flow Structures Paradigm in Aeolian Geomorphology",
abstract = "Equilibrium concepts are widespread in aeolian geomorphology. The main objective of this chapter is to reflect critically on whether a new paradigm based on coherent flow structures (CFS) is beginning to emerge as an alternative to our current understanding of aeolian processes, which is predicated on time-averaged flow and transport assessments. A survey of recent research addressing the existence and nature of CFS in aeolian systems indicates that: (1) there is as yet no convincing evidence in support of the classic bursting process or of any discrete flow structure with a characteristic topology (e.g., hairpin vortex) for the case of near-surface boundary layer flow over flat sandy surfaces (with or without saltation); (2) there are instances when near-surface vortices of varying geometry are found in association with small obstacles (e.g., logs, pebbles, vegetation clumps) on sandy surfaces, but it is not always apparent what the pattern of erosion or deposition in the vicinity of the obstacle will be given that there are additional controls that involve surface hardness and sediment delivery from upwind; (3) flow over aeolian dunes is generally well understood and very similar to flow over fluvial dunes with characteristic zonation, including flow acceleration and streamline compression on the stoss slope and a recirculation eddy and wake region in the lee; and (4) the importance of these dune-related flow zones to sediment transport response is more reliably understood through examination of a range of turbulence parameters (e.g., Reynolds stress, turbulent kinetic energy) rather than mean flow quantities alone. In order to advance our understanding of CFS in aeolian geomorphology, it will be essential to develop better technologies for high-frequency monitoring of wind and sediment flux, to focus attention on sediment transport events with specific topologies (e.g., streamers) rather than attempt to capture flow events and hope that there is an accompanying transport signal, to move beyond simple quadrant analysis and adopt analytical methods that elucidate the time-history of event signatures, and to reformulate existing time-averaged parameterizations of sediment flux to incorporate event-based information in ways that are not immediately apparent.",
author = "B.O. Bauer and I.J. Walker and A.C.W. Baas and Derek Jackson and C. McKenna-Neuman and G.F.S. Wiggs and P.A. Hesp",
year = "2013",
month = "3",
day = "1",
language = "English",
isbn = ".",
pages = "Accepted--.",
editor = "J.G. Venditti and J. Best and H. Church and R.J. Hardy",
booktitle = "Coherent Flow Structures at the Earth’s Surface",

}

Bauer, BO, Walker, IJ, Baas, ACW, Jackson, D, McKenna-Neuman, C, Wiggs, GFS & Hesp, PA 2013, Critical Reflections on the Coherent Flow Structures Paradigm in Aeolian Geomorphology. in JG Venditti, J Best, H Church & RJ Hardy (eds), Coherent Flow Structures at the Earth’s Surface. pp. Accepted-.

Critical Reflections on the Coherent Flow Structures Paradigm in Aeolian Geomorphology. / Bauer, B.O.; Walker, I.J.; Baas, A.C.W.; Jackson, Derek; McKenna-Neuman, C.; Wiggs, G.F.S.; Hesp, P.A.

Coherent Flow Structures at the Earth’s Surface. ed. / J.G. Venditti; J. Best; H. Church; R.J. Hardy. 2013. p. Accepted-.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Critical Reflections on the Coherent Flow Structures Paradigm in Aeolian Geomorphology

AU - Bauer, B.O.

AU - Walker, I.J.

AU - Baas, A.C.W.

AU - Jackson, Derek

AU - McKenna-Neuman, C.

AU - Wiggs, G.F.S.

AU - Hesp, P.A.

PY - 2013/3/1

Y1 - 2013/3/1

N2 - Equilibrium concepts are widespread in aeolian geomorphology. The main objective of this chapter is to reflect critically on whether a new paradigm based on coherent flow structures (CFS) is beginning to emerge as an alternative to our current understanding of aeolian processes, which is predicated on time-averaged flow and transport assessments. A survey of recent research addressing the existence and nature of CFS in aeolian systems indicates that: (1) there is as yet no convincing evidence in support of the classic bursting process or of any discrete flow structure with a characteristic topology (e.g., hairpin vortex) for the case of near-surface boundary layer flow over flat sandy surfaces (with or without saltation); (2) there are instances when near-surface vortices of varying geometry are found in association with small obstacles (e.g., logs, pebbles, vegetation clumps) on sandy surfaces, but it is not always apparent what the pattern of erosion or deposition in the vicinity of the obstacle will be given that there are additional controls that involve surface hardness and sediment delivery from upwind; (3) flow over aeolian dunes is generally well understood and very similar to flow over fluvial dunes with characteristic zonation, including flow acceleration and streamline compression on the stoss slope and a recirculation eddy and wake region in the lee; and (4) the importance of these dune-related flow zones to sediment transport response is more reliably understood through examination of a range of turbulence parameters (e.g., Reynolds stress, turbulent kinetic energy) rather than mean flow quantities alone. In order to advance our understanding of CFS in aeolian geomorphology, it will be essential to develop better technologies for high-frequency monitoring of wind and sediment flux, to focus attention on sediment transport events with specific topologies (e.g., streamers) rather than attempt to capture flow events and hope that there is an accompanying transport signal, to move beyond simple quadrant analysis and adopt analytical methods that elucidate the time-history of event signatures, and to reformulate existing time-averaged parameterizations of sediment flux to incorporate event-based information in ways that are not immediately apparent.

AB - Equilibrium concepts are widespread in aeolian geomorphology. The main objective of this chapter is to reflect critically on whether a new paradigm based on coherent flow structures (CFS) is beginning to emerge as an alternative to our current understanding of aeolian processes, which is predicated on time-averaged flow and transport assessments. A survey of recent research addressing the existence and nature of CFS in aeolian systems indicates that: (1) there is as yet no convincing evidence in support of the classic bursting process or of any discrete flow structure with a characteristic topology (e.g., hairpin vortex) for the case of near-surface boundary layer flow over flat sandy surfaces (with or without saltation); (2) there are instances when near-surface vortices of varying geometry are found in association with small obstacles (e.g., logs, pebbles, vegetation clumps) on sandy surfaces, but it is not always apparent what the pattern of erosion or deposition in the vicinity of the obstacle will be given that there are additional controls that involve surface hardness and sediment delivery from upwind; (3) flow over aeolian dunes is generally well understood and very similar to flow over fluvial dunes with characteristic zonation, including flow acceleration and streamline compression on the stoss slope and a recirculation eddy and wake region in the lee; and (4) the importance of these dune-related flow zones to sediment transport response is more reliably understood through examination of a range of turbulence parameters (e.g., Reynolds stress, turbulent kinetic energy) rather than mean flow quantities alone. In order to advance our understanding of CFS in aeolian geomorphology, it will be essential to develop better technologies for high-frequency monitoring of wind and sediment flux, to focus attention on sediment transport events with specific topologies (e.g., streamers) rather than attempt to capture flow events and hope that there is an accompanying transport signal, to move beyond simple quadrant analysis and adopt analytical methods that elucidate the time-history of event signatures, and to reformulate existing time-averaged parameterizations of sediment flux to incorporate event-based information in ways that are not immediately apparent.

M3 - Chapter

SN - .

SP - Accepted-.

BT - Coherent Flow Structures at the Earth’s Surface

A2 - Venditti, J.G.

A2 - Best, J.

A2 - Church, H.

A2 - Hardy, R.J.

ER -

Bauer BO, Walker IJ, Baas ACW, Jackson D, McKenna-Neuman C, Wiggs GFS et al. Critical Reflections on the Coherent Flow Structures Paradigm in Aeolian Geomorphology. In Venditti JG, Best J, Church H, Hardy RJ, editors, Coherent Flow Structures at the Earth’s Surface. 2013. p. Accepted-.