Critical care: does profusion of evidence lead to confusion in practice?

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

3 Citations (Scopus)


There have been a plethora of articles on evidence-based practice or its many derivative terms (evidence-based nursing, evidence-based medicine, evidence-based health care, etc.). However, the word ‘based’ implies an almost unquestioning belief in evidence. I will argue that the term ‘Evidence Informed Practice’ is probably more accurate. This argument will be underpinned by Archie Cochrane's ‘road to Damascus' questioning of the value of soft over hard interventions and challenge what is held up as gold-standard evidence. The differences in definitions of evidence-based practice will also be discussed. Carper's identification of ethical, aesthetic and personal knowing will be used to debunk the myth that empirical evidence is always the gold standard for care and treatment. It will be argued that empirical evidence can be ignored when it clashes with other types of evidence. Finally, the tension between certainty and agreement with evidence will be explored.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)285-290
JournalNursing in Critical Care
Issue number6
Publication statusPublished (in print/issue) - Nov 2010

Bibliographical note

Reference text: Appleby J, Walshe K, Ham C. (1995). Acting on the Evidence.
Research Report. London: NAHAT.
Baker M. (1996). Developing, disseminating and using research
information. In: Baker M, Kirk S, (eds), Research and Development
in the NHS. Oxford: Radcliffe Medical Press.
Berwick D. (2009). Don Berwick’s challenge: eliminate restrictions on
visiting hours in the intensive care unit.
intheIntensiveCareUnit.htm (accessed March 2010).
Cardiff and Vale NHS Trust. (2008). Care bundles: a global standard
for care. Presentation by Cardiff and Vale NHS Trust, Cardiff.
Carper BA. (1978). Fundamental patterns of knowing in nursing.
Advances in Nursing Science; 1: 13–23.
Cochrane A. (1989). One Man’s Medicine. London: BMJ.
Deans C, Lea D, Geyer R. (1997). Nursing research ‘down under’.
Journal of Psycho-social Nursing; 35: 25–31.
DiCenso A, Cullum N, Ciliska D. (1998). Implementation forum.
Implementing evidence-based nursing: some misconceptions.
Evidence-Based Nursing; 1: 38–40.
DonchinY, GopherD, OlinM, BadhiY, BieskyM, SprungCL,
Pizov R, Cotev S. (1995). A look into the nature and causes of
human errors in the intensive care unit. Critical Care Medicine;
23: 294–300 [Medline].
Funk SG, Tornquist EM, Champagne MT. (1995). Barriers and
facilitators of research utilisation. Nursing Clinics of North
America; 30: 395–407.
Henderson V, Harmer B. (1955). Textbook of the Principles and
Practices of Nursing, 5th edn. New York: Macmillan.
Hicks C. (1997). The dilemma of incorporating research into
clinical practice. British Journal of Nursing; 6: 511–515.
Higher Education Funding Council for England. (2009). The
Research Excellence Framework, London: HEFCE.
McKenna HP. (2009). Evidence-based practice in mental health.
Barker PJ, (ed). Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing: the Craft
of Caring, 2nd en. London: Hodder Arnold.
McKenna HP, Ashton S, Keeney SR. (2004a). Evidence based
practice in primary care: a review of the literature. International
Journal of Nursing Studies; 41: 369–378.
McKenna HP, Ashton S, Keeney SR. (2004b). Barriers to evidence
based practice. Journal of Advanced Nursing; 45:
McKenna HP, Cutliffe J, McKenna P. (2000). Evidence based
practice: demolishing some myths. Nursing Standard; 14:
Muir Gray JA. (1997). Evidence-Based Healthcare: How to Make
Health Policy and Management Decisions. New York: Churchill
Nightingale F. (1859/1980). Notes on Nursing: What it is and What
it is Not. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
Parahoo K. (2006). Nursing Research: Principals, Processes and Issues,
2nd edn. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Raulin ML. (1996). The importance of scientific theory. Science;
142: 3590.
Sackett DL, Straus SE, Richardson WS, RosenbergW, Haynes B.
(2000). Evidence-Based Medicine: How to Practice and Teach EBM.
Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
Stokes P. (2002). Philosophy: 100 Essential Thinkers. London:
Zimmerman B. (2001). Ralph Stacey’s agreement & certainty
think/main aides3.html. (accessed March 2010)


  • Critical care
  • Evidence-based practice
  • Hierarchy of evidence
  • Intensive care
  • Nursing knowledge
  • Research methods


Dive into the research topics of 'Critical care: does profusion of evidence lead to confusion in practice?'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this