Conflict Museums, Nostalgia, and Dreaming of Never Again

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

10 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Sites that mark atrocity span the globe including Villa Grimaldi in Chile, the Anne Frank Museum in Amsterdam, the Nanjing Massacre Memorial Museum in eastern China, and Robben Island in South Africa. Generally such sites seek to have some form of social and individual impact. Typically they seek to educate the next generation and prevent future forms of atrocity by revealing the past. It is contended that an overly emotional focus on the narratives of victims at such sites can limit understanding of the dynamics that cause violence. The article also explores whether there is a nostalgic element to conflict museums. Although it seems counterintuitive that nostalgia would have any place in thinking back on periods of extreme violence, it is argued that nostalgia is present in a number of ways. How this plays out in postapartheid South Africa is specifically explored. The article concludes by highlighting the dangers in South Africa of what can be termed a regenerative nostalgia for the “struggle” against apartheid and the perceived unifying peace process that followed.
LanguageEnglish
Pages268-281
JournalPeace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology
Volume18
Issue number3
Publication statusPublished - 2012

Fingerprint

nostalgia
museum
violence
massacre
peace process
memorial
apartheid
Chile
narrative
China
cause

Keywords

  • museums
  • conflict
  • transitional justice
  • nostalgia

Cite this

@article{c40ccb7d74ef47a6968aea1646097c92,
title = "Conflict Museums, Nostalgia, and Dreaming of Never Again",
abstract = "Sites that mark atrocity span the globe including Villa Grimaldi in Chile, the Anne Frank Museum in Amsterdam, the Nanjing Massacre Memorial Museum in eastern China, and Robben Island in South Africa. Generally such sites seek to have some form of social and individual impact. Typically they seek to educate the next generation and prevent future forms of atrocity by revealing the past. It is contended that an overly emotional focus on the narratives of victims at such sites can limit understanding of the dynamics that cause violence. The article also explores whether there is a nostalgic element to conflict museums. Although it seems counterintuitive that nostalgia would have any place in thinking back on periods of extreme violence, it is argued that nostalgia is present in a number of ways. How this plays out in postapartheid South Africa is specifically explored. The article concludes by highlighting the dangers in South Africa of what can be termed a regenerative nostalgia for the “struggle” against apartheid and the perceived unifying peace process that followed.",
keywords = "museums, conflict, transitional justice, nostalgia",
author = "Brandon Hamber",
year = "2012",
language = "English",
volume = "18",
pages = "268--281",
journal = "Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology",
issn = "1078-1919",
number = "3",

}

Conflict Museums, Nostalgia, and Dreaming of Never Again. / Hamber, Brandon.

In: Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology, Vol. 18, No. 3, 2012, p. 268-281.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Conflict Museums, Nostalgia, and Dreaming of Never Again

AU - Hamber, Brandon

PY - 2012

Y1 - 2012

N2 - Sites that mark atrocity span the globe including Villa Grimaldi in Chile, the Anne Frank Museum in Amsterdam, the Nanjing Massacre Memorial Museum in eastern China, and Robben Island in South Africa. Generally such sites seek to have some form of social and individual impact. Typically they seek to educate the next generation and prevent future forms of atrocity by revealing the past. It is contended that an overly emotional focus on the narratives of victims at such sites can limit understanding of the dynamics that cause violence. The article also explores whether there is a nostalgic element to conflict museums. Although it seems counterintuitive that nostalgia would have any place in thinking back on periods of extreme violence, it is argued that nostalgia is present in a number of ways. How this plays out in postapartheid South Africa is specifically explored. The article concludes by highlighting the dangers in South Africa of what can be termed a regenerative nostalgia for the “struggle” against apartheid and the perceived unifying peace process that followed.

AB - Sites that mark atrocity span the globe including Villa Grimaldi in Chile, the Anne Frank Museum in Amsterdam, the Nanjing Massacre Memorial Museum in eastern China, and Robben Island in South Africa. Generally such sites seek to have some form of social and individual impact. Typically they seek to educate the next generation and prevent future forms of atrocity by revealing the past. It is contended that an overly emotional focus on the narratives of victims at such sites can limit understanding of the dynamics that cause violence. The article also explores whether there is a nostalgic element to conflict museums. Although it seems counterintuitive that nostalgia would have any place in thinking back on periods of extreme violence, it is argued that nostalgia is present in a number of ways. How this plays out in postapartheid South Africa is specifically explored. The article concludes by highlighting the dangers in South Africa of what can be termed a regenerative nostalgia for the “struggle” against apartheid and the perceived unifying peace process that followed.

KW - museums

KW - conflict

KW - transitional justice

KW - nostalgia

M3 - Article

VL - 18

SP - 268

EP - 281

JO - Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology

T2 - Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology

JF - Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology

SN - 1078-1919

IS - 3

ER -