Colonialism, Redress and Transitional Justice: Ireland and Beyond

William Rolston, Fionnuala Ni Aolain

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The article begins by addressing the contribution and limits of postcolonial studies to the understanding of colonialism; in particular, it critiques the field's fixation on the discursive to the detriment of the material reality of colonialism. We then examine the intellectual history of transitional justice (TJ) as a field and a practice and itemize some of the criticisms made of its shortcomings, not least in relation to colonial harms. These harms are considered in detail through the specific example of colonialism in Ireland. We focus on the noticeable absence of the concept of colonialism from contemporary deliberations and practices of transition in relation to the Northern Ireland conflict. Finally, we interrogate the ability of TJ in the postcolonial period to adequately make amends for colonialism, again focusing on the Irish case, concluding that while there are major obstacles in such a task, especially in relation to “hard” measures, there are also some promising possibilities, particularly as regards “soft” measures. The lessons learnt are applicable to a range of other transitional sites grappling with postcolonial legacies.
LanguageEnglish
Pages329-348
Number of pages20
JournalState Crime Journal
Volume7
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 30 Sep 2018

Fingerprint

colonialism
colonial age
Ireland
justice
history of ideas
deliberation
fixation
criticism
redress
ability
history

Keywords

  • colonialism, transitional justice, Ireland, redress, reparation

Cite this

Rolston, William ; Ni Aolain, Fionnuala. / Colonialism, Redress and Transitional Justice: Ireland and Beyond. In: State Crime Journal. 2018 ; Vol. 7, No. 2. pp. 329-348.
@article{3464cd9907f64ee3b473e250ce758f61,
title = "Colonialism, Redress and Transitional Justice: Ireland and Beyond",
abstract = "The article begins by addressing the contribution and limits of postcolonial studies to the understanding of colonialism; in particular, it critiques the field's fixation on the discursive to the detriment of the material reality of colonialism. We then examine the intellectual history of transitional justice (TJ) as a field and a practice and itemize some of the criticisms made of its shortcomings, not least in relation to colonial harms. These harms are considered in detail through the specific example of colonialism in Ireland. We focus on the noticeable absence of the concept of colonialism from contemporary deliberations and practices of transition in relation to the Northern Ireland conflict. Finally, we interrogate the ability of TJ in the postcolonial period to adequately make amends for colonialism, again focusing on the Irish case, concluding that while there are major obstacles in such a task, especially in relation to “hard” measures, there are also some promising possibilities, particularly as regards “soft” measures. The lessons learnt are applicable to a range of other transitional sites grappling with postcolonial legacies.",
keywords = "colonialism, transitional justice, Ireland, redress, reparation",
author = "William Rolston and {Ni Aolain}, Fionnuala",
year = "2018",
month = "9",
day = "30",
doi = "10.13169/statecrime.7.2.0329",
language = "English",
volume = "7",
pages = "329--348",
journal = "State Crime Journal",
issn = "2046-6056",
number = "2",

}

Colonialism, Redress and Transitional Justice: Ireland and Beyond. / Rolston, William; Ni Aolain, Fionnuala.

In: State Crime Journal, Vol. 7, No. 2, 30.09.2018, p. 329-348.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Colonialism, Redress and Transitional Justice: Ireland and Beyond

AU - Rolston, William

AU - Ni Aolain, Fionnuala

PY - 2018/9/30

Y1 - 2018/9/30

N2 - The article begins by addressing the contribution and limits of postcolonial studies to the understanding of colonialism; in particular, it critiques the field's fixation on the discursive to the detriment of the material reality of colonialism. We then examine the intellectual history of transitional justice (TJ) as a field and a practice and itemize some of the criticisms made of its shortcomings, not least in relation to colonial harms. These harms are considered in detail through the specific example of colonialism in Ireland. We focus on the noticeable absence of the concept of colonialism from contemporary deliberations and practices of transition in relation to the Northern Ireland conflict. Finally, we interrogate the ability of TJ in the postcolonial period to adequately make amends for colonialism, again focusing on the Irish case, concluding that while there are major obstacles in such a task, especially in relation to “hard” measures, there are also some promising possibilities, particularly as regards “soft” measures. The lessons learnt are applicable to a range of other transitional sites grappling with postcolonial legacies.

AB - The article begins by addressing the contribution and limits of postcolonial studies to the understanding of colonialism; in particular, it critiques the field's fixation on the discursive to the detriment of the material reality of colonialism. We then examine the intellectual history of transitional justice (TJ) as a field and a practice and itemize some of the criticisms made of its shortcomings, not least in relation to colonial harms. These harms are considered in detail through the specific example of colonialism in Ireland. We focus on the noticeable absence of the concept of colonialism from contemporary deliberations and practices of transition in relation to the Northern Ireland conflict. Finally, we interrogate the ability of TJ in the postcolonial period to adequately make amends for colonialism, again focusing on the Irish case, concluding that while there are major obstacles in such a task, especially in relation to “hard” measures, there are also some promising possibilities, particularly as regards “soft” measures. The lessons learnt are applicable to a range of other transitional sites grappling with postcolonial legacies.

KW - colonialism, transitional justice, Ireland, redress, reparation

U2 - 10.13169/statecrime.7.2.0329

DO - 10.13169/statecrime.7.2.0329

M3 - Article

VL - 7

SP - 329

EP - 348

JO - State Crime Journal

T2 - State Crime Journal

JF - State Crime Journal

SN - 2046-6056

IS - 2

ER -