Brexit and devolved social security in Scotland: a tale of two referenda

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This article discusses the possible impact of withdrawal from the EU on social security in Scotland. Despite the relatively limited role of EU membership in shaping the UK social security system, the effects of Brexit could be significant, even if largely indirect. The recent EU and independence referenda have allowed devolved elites to portray Scotland as more concerned with social justice and more internationalist than the UK as a whole. Maintaining or enhancing EU citizens’ social rights would be in keeping with this self-image. The Scottish Government’s view that Scotland has a greater need for immigration than other parts of the UK provides a further, pragmatic argument for enhancing its attractiveness as a destination by allowing migrants to access family benefits in particular. The limited extent of devolved social security competences means this is not currently an option. Even if the push for a second independence referendum following the Brexit vote has been put on hold for now, the possibility remains that the Scottish Government will seek renegotiation of the constitutional settlement. Social security is an obvious field for further devolution. The door could hence be opened to divergence from DWP on the entitlements of EU migrants.
LanguageEnglish
Pages56-73
JournalJournal of Social Security Law
Volume25
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - 19 Mar 2018

Fingerprint

referendum
social security
EU
migrant
EU citizen
social rights
social attraction
withdrawal
divergence
self-image
social justice
decentralization
voter
immigration
pragmatics
elite

Keywords

  • Social security
  • Brexit
  • Welfare state
  • European Union
  • Devolution
  • Scotland
  • Social rights

Cite this

@article{e92ca13898774045b163bc0ab2bb9c32,
title = "Brexit and devolved social security in Scotland: a tale of two referenda",
abstract = "This article discusses the possible impact of withdrawal from the EU on social security in Scotland. Despite the relatively limited role of EU membership in shaping the UK social security system, the effects of Brexit could be significant, even if largely indirect. The recent EU and independence referenda have allowed devolved elites to portray Scotland as more concerned with social justice and more internationalist than the UK as a whole. Maintaining or enhancing EU citizens’ social rights would be in keeping with this self-image. The Scottish Government’s view that Scotland has a greater need for immigration than other parts of the UK provides a further, pragmatic argument for enhancing its attractiveness as a destination by allowing migrants to access family benefits in particular. The limited extent of devolved social security competences means this is not currently an option. Even if the push for a second independence referendum following the Brexit vote has been put on hold for now, the possibility remains that the Scottish Government will seek renegotiation of the constitutional settlement. Social security is an obvious field for further devolution. The door could hence be opened to divergence from DWP on the entitlements of EU migrants.",
keywords = "Social security, Brexit, Welfare state, European Union, Devolution, Scotland, Social rights",
author = "Mark Simpson",
note = "Compliant in UIR (see uploaded file '39823 evidence of compliance in UIR')",
year = "2018",
month = "3",
day = "19",
language = "English",
volume = "25",
pages = "56--73",
number = "1",

}

Brexit and devolved social security in Scotland: a tale of two referenda. / Simpson, Mark.

Vol. 25, No. 1, 19.03.2018, p. 56-73.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Brexit and devolved social security in Scotland: a tale of two referenda

AU - Simpson, Mark

N1 - Compliant in UIR (see uploaded file '39823 evidence of compliance in UIR')

PY - 2018/3/19

Y1 - 2018/3/19

N2 - This article discusses the possible impact of withdrawal from the EU on social security in Scotland. Despite the relatively limited role of EU membership in shaping the UK social security system, the effects of Brexit could be significant, even if largely indirect. The recent EU and independence referenda have allowed devolved elites to portray Scotland as more concerned with social justice and more internationalist than the UK as a whole. Maintaining or enhancing EU citizens’ social rights would be in keeping with this self-image. The Scottish Government’s view that Scotland has a greater need for immigration than other parts of the UK provides a further, pragmatic argument for enhancing its attractiveness as a destination by allowing migrants to access family benefits in particular. The limited extent of devolved social security competences means this is not currently an option. Even if the push for a second independence referendum following the Brexit vote has been put on hold for now, the possibility remains that the Scottish Government will seek renegotiation of the constitutional settlement. Social security is an obvious field for further devolution. The door could hence be opened to divergence from DWP on the entitlements of EU migrants.

AB - This article discusses the possible impact of withdrawal from the EU on social security in Scotland. Despite the relatively limited role of EU membership in shaping the UK social security system, the effects of Brexit could be significant, even if largely indirect. The recent EU and independence referenda have allowed devolved elites to portray Scotland as more concerned with social justice and more internationalist than the UK as a whole. Maintaining or enhancing EU citizens’ social rights would be in keeping with this self-image. The Scottish Government’s view that Scotland has a greater need for immigration than other parts of the UK provides a further, pragmatic argument for enhancing its attractiveness as a destination by allowing migrants to access family benefits in particular. The limited extent of devolved social security competences means this is not currently an option. Even if the push for a second independence referendum following the Brexit vote has been put on hold for now, the possibility remains that the Scottish Government will seek renegotiation of the constitutional settlement. Social security is an obvious field for further devolution. The door could hence be opened to divergence from DWP on the entitlements of EU migrants.

KW - Social security

KW - Brexit

KW - Welfare state

KW - European Union

KW - Devolution

KW - Scotland

KW - Social rights

M3 - Article

VL - 25

SP - 56

EP - 73

IS - 1

ER -