Are Police-Led Social Crime Prevention Initiatives Effective?: A Process and Outcome Evaluation of a UK Youth Intervention

Jon Hobson, Kenny Lynch, Brian Payne, Liz Ellis

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Police-led interventions with “at-risk” young people raise a number of debates around policing in society including the allocation of resources at a time of fiscal austerity, the extent to which the police should prioritize the safety and well-being of young people, and the role that the police should take in preventing youth crime. This article explores the impact and effectiveness of a police-led social crime prevention initiative in England. It adopts the QUALIPREV approach by Rummens, Hardyns,Vander Laenen, and Pauwels on behalf of the European Crime Prevention Network to analyze the data allowing for a detailed and replicable analysis of core aspects including police engagement, risk management, offending rates, and police–community relations. Drawing on comparisons between the UK case study and previous studies on police-led social crime prevention projects in Australia and Canada, this article identifies a number of common challenges for schemes of this nature including problems with multiagency working, developing a clear project identity, unequal resources across different locations, and the difficulty in recruiting and retaining volunteers. However, there were also significant benefits to such schemes, including positive impacts on offending rates, engagement of at-risk young people, and wider benefits to the communities within which the young people live, including participation, volunteering, and reduction in risks of community harm. A cost–benefit analysis also shows such schemes have the potential to offer significant savings to the criminal justice system as a whole.
LanguageEnglish
Pages1-22
Number of pages22
JournalInternational Criminal Justice Review
Volumex
Issue numberx
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 5 Dec 2018

Fingerprint

crime prevention
police
evaluation
community
cost-benefit analysis
resources
risk management
savings
well-being
justice
offense
Canada
participation

Keywords

  • Social Crime prevention, Police-led intervention, Working for reward, Youth offending

Cite this

@article{36a67078919a49258a9533be8004a91a,
title = "Are Police-Led Social Crime Prevention Initiatives Effective?: A Process and Outcome Evaluation of a UK Youth Intervention",
abstract = "Police-led interventions with “at-risk” young people raise a number of debates around policing in society including the allocation of resources at a time of fiscal austerity, the extent to which the police should prioritize the safety and well-being of young people, and the role that the police should take in preventing youth crime. This article explores the impact and effectiveness of a police-led social crime prevention initiative in England. It adopts the QUALIPREV approach by Rummens, Hardyns,Vander Laenen, and Pauwels on behalf of the European Crime Prevention Network to analyze the data allowing for a detailed and replicable analysis of core aspects including police engagement, risk management, offending rates, and police–community relations. Drawing on comparisons between the UK case study and previous studies on police-led social crime prevention projects in Australia and Canada, this article identifies a number of common challenges for schemes of this nature including problems with multiagency working, developing a clear project identity, unequal resources across different locations, and the difficulty in recruiting and retaining volunteers. However, there were also significant benefits to such schemes, including positive impacts on offending rates, engagement of at-risk young people, and wider benefits to the communities within which the young people live, including participation, volunteering, and reduction in risks of community harm. A cost–benefit analysis also shows such schemes have the potential to offer significant savings to the criminal justice system as a whole.",
keywords = "Social Crime prevention, Police-led intervention, Working for reward, Youth offending",
author = "Jon Hobson and Kenny Lynch and Brian Payne and Liz Ellis",
note = "The author had difficulties getting evidence of the acceptance date so there was a delay in getting the output validated within three months of acceptance date. Was 'validated' within three months of publication date. It was also deposited in a co-authors repository within three months of acceptance. See email in Other Files section.",
year = "2018",
month = "12",
day = "5",
doi = "10.1177/1057567718814891",
language = "English",
volume = "x",
pages = "1--22",
journal = "International Criminal Justice Review",
issn = "1057-5677",
number = "x",

}

Are Police-Led Social Crime Prevention Initiatives Effective?: A Process and Outcome Evaluation of a UK Youth Intervention. / Hobson, Jon; Lynch, Kenny; Payne, Brian; Ellis, Liz.

In: International Criminal Justice Review, Vol. x, No. x, 05.12.2018, p. 1-22.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Are Police-Led Social Crime Prevention Initiatives Effective?: A Process and Outcome Evaluation of a UK Youth Intervention

AU - Hobson, Jon

AU - Lynch, Kenny

AU - Payne, Brian

AU - Ellis, Liz

N1 - The author had difficulties getting evidence of the acceptance date so there was a delay in getting the output validated within three months of acceptance date. Was 'validated' within three months of publication date. It was also deposited in a co-authors repository within three months of acceptance. See email in Other Files section.

PY - 2018/12/5

Y1 - 2018/12/5

N2 - Police-led interventions with “at-risk” young people raise a number of debates around policing in society including the allocation of resources at a time of fiscal austerity, the extent to which the police should prioritize the safety and well-being of young people, and the role that the police should take in preventing youth crime. This article explores the impact and effectiveness of a police-led social crime prevention initiative in England. It adopts the QUALIPREV approach by Rummens, Hardyns,Vander Laenen, and Pauwels on behalf of the European Crime Prevention Network to analyze the data allowing for a detailed and replicable analysis of core aspects including police engagement, risk management, offending rates, and police–community relations. Drawing on comparisons between the UK case study and previous studies on police-led social crime prevention projects in Australia and Canada, this article identifies a number of common challenges for schemes of this nature including problems with multiagency working, developing a clear project identity, unequal resources across different locations, and the difficulty in recruiting and retaining volunteers. However, there were also significant benefits to such schemes, including positive impacts on offending rates, engagement of at-risk young people, and wider benefits to the communities within which the young people live, including participation, volunteering, and reduction in risks of community harm. A cost–benefit analysis also shows such schemes have the potential to offer significant savings to the criminal justice system as a whole.

AB - Police-led interventions with “at-risk” young people raise a number of debates around policing in society including the allocation of resources at a time of fiscal austerity, the extent to which the police should prioritize the safety and well-being of young people, and the role that the police should take in preventing youth crime. This article explores the impact and effectiveness of a police-led social crime prevention initiative in England. It adopts the QUALIPREV approach by Rummens, Hardyns,Vander Laenen, and Pauwels on behalf of the European Crime Prevention Network to analyze the data allowing for a detailed and replicable analysis of core aspects including police engagement, risk management, offending rates, and police–community relations. Drawing on comparisons between the UK case study and previous studies on police-led social crime prevention projects in Australia and Canada, this article identifies a number of common challenges for schemes of this nature including problems with multiagency working, developing a clear project identity, unequal resources across different locations, and the difficulty in recruiting and retaining volunteers. However, there were also significant benefits to such schemes, including positive impacts on offending rates, engagement of at-risk young people, and wider benefits to the communities within which the young people live, including participation, volunteering, and reduction in risks of community harm. A cost–benefit analysis also shows such schemes have the potential to offer significant savings to the criminal justice system as a whole.

KW - Social Crime prevention, Police-led intervention, Working for reward, Youth offending

U2 - 10.1177/1057567718814891

DO - 10.1177/1057567718814891

M3 - Article

VL - x

SP - 1

EP - 22

JO - International Criminal Justice Review

T2 - International Criminal Justice Review

JF - International Criminal Justice Review

SN - 1057-5677

IS - x

ER -